OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
146438678 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1240984678 ist keine Reitanlage/kein Pferdehof (leisure=horse_riding), sondern ein Reitplatz. Für Reitplätze gibt's den Preset "Reitplatz", der die Tags leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian verwendet. Vgl.
osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding

146432034 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
was heißt denn hier "Korrektur"? Der Reitplatz war so getaggt wie andere Reitplätze auch und ein Reitplatz ist keine Reitanlage/kein Reiterhof im Sinne von osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding

Die anderen Flächen, die du mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt hast, sehen auch aus wie Reitplätze (bzw, einer Roundpen):
way/1240945688
way/1240970549
way/1240972635

146425536 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1240892116 and way/1240892117 look like riding arenas and not like riding centres (leisure=horse_riding). Also it does not make sense to map one arena inside of another. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and iD has a preset for them that does that.
Compare
leisure=horse_riding
way/204551023 (correct example)

146381040 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1240589249 does not look like a riding center (leisure=horse_riding), it looks more like a riding arena, I think. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. In JOSM you can add these tags with the preset for sport=equestrian ("Equestrian Sport").

Compare
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
way/498143073

146259211 almost 2 years ago

Or if it is a riding arena, the leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian would be better, see osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding

146259211 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
Are you sure that way/60851728 is an equestrian center? You have changed it from leisure=track to leisure=horse_riding, but in bing etc. it looks more like a track to me. Maybe it should just have sport=equestrian instead of sport=multi (?), I don't know.

146223924 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1239464430 and way/1239464431 are no riding centres (leisure=horse_riding), they are riding arenas. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and iD has a separate preset for them.
The riding centre to which these arenas belong can/should be mapped as a sepatare object (area or node) representing the whole centre; this object may then get the tag leisure=horse_riding, examples;
way/453737341#map=18/53.87989/-2.01987&layers=P
node/8379284513#map=19/53.66032/-1.86635&layers=P
Sea also
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding

146217106 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
hier hast du das Tag leisure=horse_riding ("Reitanlage") einmal für den Reiterhof Schmiemann und dann nochmal für die Reithalle von dem Reiterhof verwendet. Das ist nicht so sinnvoll weil dann möglicherweise an der Stelle zwei Reitanlagen auf manchen Karten erscheinen obwohl es in Wirklichkeit ja nur eine gibt. Ich würde das horse_riding-Tag von der Reithalle entfernen und contact/facebook/phone/website an die Gesamtfläche von dem Reiterhof Schmiemann verlegen. Das würde dann prinzipiell so aussehen wie z.B. bei way/687284438. Vgl. osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding#Wann_nicht_verwenden

Ich habe gesehen, dass bei dir in der Gegend das Tag leisure=horse_riding öfters an Gebäuden verwendet wurde. Dafür ist es aber nicht gedacht und global kommt das glücklicherweise auch eher selten vor, siehe https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/leisure=horse_riding#combinations

146084442 almost 2 years ago

Thanks. In this case maybe "riding cemter" wasn't wrong. Is it https://www.yelp.com/biz/griffith-park-horse-rentals-glendale ? Maybe you can add some additional tags like name=*, description=*, website=* and/or operator=* so that one can get an idea what it is without visiting it.

146084442 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
Is way/1238452688 really a horse riding cemter? This would be an exiremely small riding center! A riding center is some thing like
way/895398959,
way/918929394
or
way/304041050
(to take some from your area). See also
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding

146056970 almost 2 years ago

JFYI: There is a guy in the US who is apparently currently trying to figure out how to tag something like this (riding for the disabled), see healthcare:speciality=animal-assisted

146030017 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
You have tagged the building leisure=horse_riding but each building should have a building tag, otherwise it will not be rendered as a building on the maps. If the building is an indoor arena you can use building=riding_hall and the iD editor has a preset for that.
The tag leisure=horse_riding is for complete riding centres (and not for buildings). In this case the riding centre seems to be https://www.facebook.com/p/Chiverton-Riding-Centre-100056007231652/. I would recommend to map it with a separate object (area or node), e.g. like way/1008067851 (Eccleston Equestrian Centre or node/4920681807 (Eborlands Equestrian Centre)

146029949 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
You have retagged the building to a riding centre (tag leisure=horse_riding). I think that this was not a good idea. Each building should have a building tag, otherwise it will not be rendered as a building on the maps. If the building is an indoor arena you can use building=riding_hall and the iD editor has a preset for that.
The tag leisure=horse_riding is for a complete riding centre (not for just some of it's buildings); in this case it is represented by way/351529199 (Colraine Equestrian Centre) with leisure=sports_centre + sport=equestrian, which is an alternative tagging.

Related:
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
building=riding_hall
way/1008067851 (example)

145967160 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1237585347 sieht aus wie ein Reitplatz und nicht wie eine Reitanlage im Sinn von osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding. Reitplätze werden in OSM normalerweise mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian getaggt und das kann man in JOSM mit dem Preset für sport=equestrian ("Pferdesport") machen.

145855133 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/275833045
and
way/1236700645
look like buildings on Bing, but you have (re)tagged them as riding centres. In OSM every building should have a building tag in order to be rendered as a building on the map. For different building types we have different building tags, e.g. building=stable, building=riding_hall, building=barn, ...
The tag leisure=horse_riding is for the whole area of a riding centre (and not for some buildings of it).
Compare
osm.wiki/FR:Équitation
way/198048577 (example)

145780575 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
You have retagged this object from a building to a riding stables (leisure=horse_riding). Therefore it is no longer rendered as a building on the map. But it looks like a building on Bing. If it is a stable building you can tag it building=stable (and there is also a preset for that in iD).

The tag leisure=horse_riding shall be used for the whole facility. I would recommend to add a separate object (area or node) for this whole facility .

And way/816835472 doesn't seem to be a riding stables either, it looks like a riding arena and should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (and there is also a preset for that in iD).

Compare
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
way/1005924061
node/2434557134

145801484 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1236310825 ist nur ein Reitplatz und müsste mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian getaggt werden. Das kann man in JOSM mit dem Preset für sport=equestrian machen. Das Tag leisure=horse_riding gehört an das Gesamtgelände way/604233409.
Vgl.
osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding
way/37590783

145734982 almost 2 years ago

Könnte ich auch nicht besser. Bin ja kein Kartograph!

145734982 almost 2 years ago

Vielleicht so ungefähr:
node/8438968998
(nur eine Idee).

145734982 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
du hast von way/140883058 das building Tag entfernt; deswegen ist dieses Gebäude jetzt nicht mehr als Gebäude auf der Karte zu sehen. iD hat das Tag vermutlich automatisch entfernt weil du die Fläche mit dem Preset für Reitanlagen bearbeitet hast, das Tag leisure=horse_riding jedoch nicht für spezielle Gebäude, sondern für das Gesamtgelände der Reitanlage verwendet werden sollte (siehe Wiki). Vielleicht legst du lieber ein gesondertes Objekt (Fläche oder Knoten) für die "Reitanlage" an.