OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
144306132 about 2 years ago

Hi,
I think the way you mapped the equestrian center is not ideal. You have mapped the outline of a building and tagged it with leisure=horse_riding. This tag should not be used for one building, but for the whole riding center. But each building should get a building tag, otherwise it won't render as a building. I would recommend mapping the equestrian center somehow like these:
way/624385595#map=18/52.63781/-7.21116&layers=P
way/554528453#map=17/53.33848/-6.38137&layers=P

See also:
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
building=riding_hall

144284337 about 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1225635179 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and in iD the is a separate preset for riding arenas which does that. Compare leisure=horse_riding

144239931 about 2 years ago

Hi, falls es sich bei way/1225398079 um einen Reitplatz handelt (was ich nach den Luftbildern stark vermute) wäre ein entsprechendes Tagging als osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz sinnvoller (analog zu changeset/123670098)

144246122 about 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1225427360 sieht auf dem Luftbild eher aus wie ein Reitplatz (leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian); vgl. way/28114386 und osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding

144179986 about 2 years ago

Hi,
Why did you retag way/1115332843 ? Now there are 2 nested equestrian centres mepped (way/1115332843 inside of way/1115332846), which makes no sense.

144115011 about 2 years ago

Hi,
du hast hier alle möglichen Reitplätze und sogar eine Führanlage fälschlicherweise mit leisure=horse_riding ("Reitanlage") getaggt, nur die eigentliche Fläche der Reitanlage "Pferdetreffpunkt Abel" (way/123023994) hast du nicht damit getaggt. Vergleich das mal mit
way/806126313 (Reitverein Schwetzingen),
way/203861181 (Reitanlage Moser) oder
way/108685618 (Fießer-Hof)
und lies mal
osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding
Kannst du deine Ergänzungen vielleicht noch weiter verbessern?

144041507 about 2 years ago

Yes. Search for "arena" and you can select the appropriate preset.

144048667 about 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1223759788 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre. Riding arenas should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (iD-preset "Horseback Riding / Rodeo Arena").

This is also the case for way/513969498 (jumping arena) and for way/136036265.

way/1223756381 looks like some paddocks perhaps, but not like a riding centre.

I don't know what way/1223763437 is, but for a riding centre it is too small. The tag leisure=horse_riding shall only be used for complete riding centres, see osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
Example: way/533610195

144041507 about 2 years ago

No, the most fitting tag combination for an outdoor riding arena is leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, this is set by preset "Horseback Riding / Rodeo Arena". I noticed that, if you searched for "equestrian arena", this preset was not listed. This will hopefully be improved in the next release, see https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/pull/1055

143989754 about 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1223337119 is obviously not a racecourse, see https://www.facebook.com/KonjickiKlubClassic/ ; it should be tagged differently, see:
- osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
- way/856426537
- osm.org/changeset (similar problem)

143867832 about 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1222527768 does not look like a riding centre (leisure=horse_riding) and is too small for sport=horse_racing. I guess it is a riding arena which should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. In JOSM you can use the preset for sport=equestrian to set these tags.

143879897 about 2 years ago

Hi,
du hast hier das Gebäude way/1222604985 ergänzt und mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt. Es gab aber vorher schon die Fläche way/153402380, die auch mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt war. Man sollte das Tag für einen Reiterhof nicht mehrfach verwenden, denn es gibt den ja in Wirklichkeit nur ein Mal. Außerdem soll es nicht für einzelne Teile (z.B. Gebäude) eines Reiterhofs, sondern für die gesamte Fläche verwendet werden. Vgl. osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding
Daher würde ich vorschlagen, dieses Tag an dem Gebäude zu löschen.

143820695 about 2 years ago

This link is better:
way/1007620230#map=19/53.66726/-2.74177&layers=P

143820695 about 2 years ago

Hi,
The indoor arena is a building and should have a building tag (building)=*, otherwise it will not be rendered as a building. The tag leisure=horse_riding is not a building tag, it is for complete riding centres, in this case it would be appropriate for the whole Cloverleaf Equine Center (and not for the indoor arena alone). Here is an example of an indoor arena as a part of an equestrian center:
way/1007620230#layers=P

Compare wiki pages:
leisure=horse_riding
osm.wiki/Tag%3Abuilding%3Driding_hall

143797289 about 2 years ago

Hi,
es ist nicht sinnvoll, eine Reitanlage (leisure=horse_riding) innerhalb einer anderen zu mappen, wie du das gemacht hast. Die äußere, way/692970565, ist ok (vermutlich https://www.reiterhof-listemann.de). Die innere, way/692970566, ist sicherlich die Reithalle; dafür gibt es das Tag osm.wiki/DE:Tag:building=riding_hall. Dafür gibt's in iD momentan noch kein Preset, das muss man da eintippen.

143794969 about 2 years ago

Hi,
Why did you do that? Isn't it a racecourse?
Compare
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Racecourse_(horse_racing)

143728643 about 2 years ago

The area you have mapped is just the riding arena, regardless of who uses it. The entire equestrian center is surely larger; at least the bleachers are also part of it and probably or possibly other buildings or areas as well. Just like the International Stadium is larger than just the pitch it contains. Here are some examples of riding centers:
Kuwait Riding Center
way/336182179
نادي الفروسية
way/1191554627
Andalus Horse Ranch
way/581279550

143728643 about 2 years ago

Hi,
way/1221719450 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. In JOSM you can use the preset for sport=equestrian to set these tags. Compare osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding

143733298 about 2 years ago

Hi,
compare
- osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Racecourse_(horse_racing)
- osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
- way/856426537

143690908 about 2 years ago

Hallo,
schön, dass du deine Ponyschule eingetragen hast. Aber dabei hast den Knoten für der Ort "Münchsreuth" verwendet. Jetzt ist kein Knoten mehr mit place=village + name=Münchsreuth da. Ich kenne mich in der Gegend nicht aus, aber ich nehme an, dass der Knoten richtig war und du stattdessen lieber einen neuen Knoten für die Ponyschule hättest anlegen sollen, genau an dem Ort, wo sie ist.