OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
100505764 over 4 years ago

First, let me state that I'm not skilled enough to say what I'm going to say with confidence so if you feel otherwise I will not stop you if you revert the change I made.

However, I'm not convinced that this parcel is or should be mapped as Chugach State Park for two reasons.

One, the legal description of the parcel is T14N R2W SEC 13 or

Township 14 North Range 2 West Section 13, as I read it.

The designation in the statute link I see is Township 14 North Range 1 West Section 13, as I read it.

So the Range is different. I don't know enough to say if that means it's different or not, only to say they are different on paper.

Secondly, the area there is commonly recognized as the Lions Club park so it would be confusing to the general user to see a discontinuous Chugach State Park. This is also not a rock solid thought but to me it makes sense to label it as it is done physically.

These are my thoughts and not hard arguments so please feel free to respond or make the change you can back up that you think is correct.

Cheers!

100505764 over 4 years ago

I'm on mobile only now but I'll take a look before tomorrow noon.

100309240 almost 5 years ago

nice edit!

100162910 almost 5 years ago

nice edit!

100152965 almost 5 years ago

For the case of Crow pass, this trail already exists. Please be careful not to add duplicate features.

100007161 almost 5 years ago

It is!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xJPcJdcp8gE&ab_channel=AnchorageDailyNews

99625301 almost 5 years ago

This is interesting. I corrected an N street that was in osm as North Street just few blocks away.

99474967 almost 5 years ago

Map_Manager has responded to my direct message to me with the following:

"We the property owners do not want you or anyone else adding tracks or other markings to our property without our express permission.

We have already dealt with the Municipality on this issue. Contact Tina Miller if you have any questions about that.

Potter Valley Property Owners
*******************************"

99469455 almost 5 years ago

Please tell me why this should be removed? I believe you are acting as a vandal of open street map but am giving you time to respond to edits. I will revert your edits if I don't hear back from you.

99469198 almost 5 years ago

What is the proper designation in your view?

99198892 almost 5 years ago

This street is already mapped by the municipality here: https://muniorg.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=493d6c82574c43d981bd2aaa384b3d60

99198892 almost 5 years ago

These are verified roads and trails. If they are private then they should remain and be tagged as private property. It is also visible by aerial imagery. They should not have been removed.

Please refer to the article on the osm wiki here on what is acceptable to map:
osm.wiki/Verifiability.

99155240 almost 5 years ago

These are verified roads and trails. If they are private then they should remain and be tagged as private property. It is also visible by aerial imagery. They should not have been removed.

Please refer to the article on the osm wiki here on what is acceptable to map:
osm.wiki/Verifiability

98971736 almost 5 years ago

thanks for the edits.

98101877 almost 5 years ago

All your edits are great! I hope you do more.

97515444 almost 5 years ago

well done! Chugach State Park is a hard one to work with.

96462534 almost 5 years ago

nice edit.

96484398 almost 5 years ago

I can see you have focused your attention to churches. I've put in work to update the geometry and metadata for most churches in Anchorage. If you have suggestions for improvements please let me know.

94655100 about 5 years ago

Excellent Edit! :)

95172737 about 5 years ago

Why did you remove the State Examiner's Office? This is a very large edit that should have been split up.