Gregory Peony's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 171713266 | 3 months ago | You corretly assessed the possibility for a car to use these highways and changed the tagging part way along a highway to reflect this: well done! The highways could be more accurate: enure that the bends in the highwayas are identifiable. When mapping highways, please trace their shape accurately. Accurate highways aid navigation and prevent issues like data overlaps. Zoom in so that you can see the width of the highway. The lines you trace to represent highways should follow their centre; so add more nodes the more they curve and click at the start and end of straight sections, as a rule of thumb keep the lines you trace within the width of the highway you're mapping. Following tracks or road markings can help.If the highway fans out into several close alternative paths to the same destination then you only need to trace the median or what looks like the most used route. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/ |
| 171712863 | 3 months ago | All highways you added here look valid accurate and appropriately tagged. Tip: check other imagery sources if the primary one has cloud cover like it does here. Please focus your efforts on highways that link settlements. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710706 | 3 months ago | Welcome to OSM! Thank you for submitting a custom changeset comment! Just bear in mind that id you're contributing as part of a project don't strip the hashtags becasue these are used to track proejct stats. You corectly identified highways and assessed their width. You clearly took care when tracing the highways, thanks for that. It looks like you may have slightly confused by the path of the northern highway; this is becasue it crosses a waterway I'd say given the context it's likely accurate enough. You correctly identified a residential area and tagged it correctly; rememeber to add a place= node to mark what kind of settlement it is. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171712623 | 3 months ago | You spotted highways in imagery. You correctly assessed the width of the western two highways but the eastern one is in fact wide enough for a car evidenced by the tracks on the ground. For the puropses of this project please consider whether the highways you're mapping connect settlements; those which don't are beyond the scope of the project. When mapping highways, please trace their shape accurately. Accurate highways aid navigation and prevent issues like data overlaps. Zoom in so that you can see the width of the highway. The lines you trace to represent highways should follow their centre; so add more nodes the more they curve and click at the start and end of straight sections, as a rule of thumb keep the lines you trace within the width of the highway you're mapping. Following tracks or road markings can help.If the highway fans out into several close alternative paths to the same destination then you only need to trace the median or what looks like the most used route. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/ |
| 171712092 | 3 months ago | When mapping highways, please trace their shape accurately. Accurate highways aid navigation and prevent issues like data overlaps. Zoom in so that you can see the width of the highway. The lines you trace to represent highways should follow their centre; so add more nodes the more they curve and click at the start and end of straight sections, as a rule of thumb keep the lines you trace within the width of the highway you're mapping. Following tracks or road markings can help.If the highway fans out into several close alternative paths to the same destination then you only need to trace the median or what looks like the most used route.
|
| 171711940 | 3 months ago | This residential area could be extended north. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171711300 | 3 months ago | See how I tagged them here https://osmcha.org/changesets/171711518
|
| 171709044 | 3 months ago | see how I mapped these residential areas and place points here https://osmcha.org/changesets/171712273
|
| 171709044 | 3 months ago | Hi, it looks like you mapped these residential areas with a similar workflow to what would be used to map building footprints. This has led to less accurate mapping. We square footprints after tracing them becasue the shape is likely square, however this is not necessarily the case with residential areas. For instance a city block may be accurately mapped as a squared residential area, but these rural settlements likely have more complex residential areas. You can use more than 4 nodes, you know. Consider natural boundaries, the colour of the ground, and how the land is being used when mapping residnetial areas. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171711300 | 3 months ago | These are highways but please check the width of the highway and check for visible evidence of use by cars when tagging, and consider the context such as the topology of the area; steeper routes are more likely to be paths. Please keep this feedback in mind when contributing in future. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710798 | 3 months ago | The tagging of the highway you added looks valid, but I would continue it southward instead of east becasue that looks like the 'main line' of the highway.
|
| 171711061 | 3 months ago | You correctly identified a highway here but it appears wide enough for a car to travel on and could be slightly more accurate. When mapping highways, please trace their shape accurately. Accurate highways aid navigation and prevent issues like data overlaps. Zoom in so that you can see the width of the highway. The lines you trace to represent highways should follow their centre; so add more nodes the more they curve and click at the start and end of straight sections, as a rule of thumb keep the lines you trace within the width of the highway you're mapping. Following tracks or road markings can help.If the highway fans out into several close alternative paths to the same destination then you only need to trace the median or what looks like the most used route. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710574 | 3 months ago | You are idenitfying groups of buildings but on a few occasions you tagged areas as place= rather than adding a POI with that tag. The area should be tagged as residential landuse. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710746 | 3 months ago | You correctly tagged the highway you added. PLease follow the centre of highways when mapping them; use more nodes the more the highway curves and try to keep the line data within the width of the road. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710133 | 3 months ago | Welcome to OSM! You correctly identified and tagged the settlement you added here. Highways should follow the centre of the road; use more nodes on turns and curves. The highway you added looks wide enough for a car to use so should be tagged as unclassified. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710258 | 3 months ago | This highway could be slightly more accurate but it's certainly wide enough for a car. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710289 | 3 months ago | Welcome to OSM! You have correctly identified settlements and highways. The settlements have been correctly tagged but could be at times slightly more accurate (smaller). These highways are more likely uncassified; residential highways are only typically found in larger settlements with several roads. Highways should follow the centre of roads; use more nodes when mapping turns and curves. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710305 | 3 months ago | Welcome to OSM! you correctly identified settlements and highways but the residential areas here are incorrectly tagged. The area should be tagged as a residential area and a POI should be tagged with the place value e.g. hamlet. Highways and residential areas should not share nodes; hold alt to prevent this. Please keep this feedback in mind when contributing in future. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710325 | 3 months ago | Welcome to OSM! The residential area and place tag look accurate, but the highways you added could be more accurate since highways should follow the centre of paths. Add more nodes on corners and curves. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|
| 171710358 | 3 months ago | Welcome to OSM! Do not conect highways and residential areas, hold alt in ID to prevent this. The residential area you mapped in the north is likely a cemetary. Place tags look appropriate. Highways should follow the centre of the road; use more nodes on curves, turns and bends. Please keep this feedback in mind when contributing in future. Thank you for your contribution. If you want to experience the OSM community or to get timely feedback from other mappers; I recommend that you attend a mapathon. You can find events here https://osmcal.org/
|