Glassman's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 141896513 | over 2 years ago | This looks more like a leisure=playground. Can you review?
|
| 141896458 | over 2 years ago | This app requires that I review everything as good or bad. There is no in between. When I mark it as bad, it may only be that it doesn't fit the OSM tagging scheme. I'll leave a changeset comment with what I found. The trail overlaps with the pond, and connects to the pond in places. Can you redraw the footway so it doesn't connect or overlap with the detention pond? Also, there is an existing footway that looks like it should be connected to your footway. Not your issue, but is the service road closed to foot traffic? I'll send you more info on OSM in a message
|
| 141893984 | over 2 years ago | Here are some tips to help you out mapping in OSM. We don't use descriptive names, like name=house or name=line. The tags are sufficient. I made the updates. Also you added a short footway to the ocean and name it a trail. OSM was started in England so we use British terminology for tagging. A footway is what we would call a sidewalk in the US. A path is what we would call a trail. I updated the feature. Lastly - you removed a driveway. Not sure why. It appears on the latest imagery. I went ahead and added it back. Let me know if it really doesn't exist. I'll send you more info on OSM in a message.
|
| 141843694 | over 2 years ago | Did you notice that the entire golf course is already tagged as the Rolling Hills Golf Course? You might want to remove your node or change it to what is in the building. |
| 141770039 | over 2 years ago | This app requires that I review everything as good or bad. There is no in between. When I mark it as bad, it may only be that it doesn't fit the OSM tagging scheme. I'll leave a changeset comment with what I found. This is a residential neighborhood. Not a retail location.
|
| 141667235 | over 2 years ago | #TIPS: square buildings by selecting the outline then just type a "q" Also - save and upload your edits before moving to a distant location.
|
| 141658636 | over 2 years ago | #TIP: Add a changeset comment - it will help you and others.
|
| 141663936 | over 2 years ago | Here is a quote from the wiki " Many privately owned roads are freely accessible for the general public without prior permission- in such case access=private would be wrong and it may be access=permissive if the owner can revoke this permission at their own discretion" See access=* If you want the road to be access=private I'd suggest either adding a no-trespassing sign or a closed gate.
|
| 141663936 | over 2 years ago | I suspect that Agate Beach Lane is privately maintained. That doesn't make it a private road. You can tag the operator= of the road. As it was previously tagged as access=destination seems more appropriate. You can also add the tag noexit=yes to the last node on the way to help discourage people from using the road. However any geospatial router wouldn't use the road to get to the park. Please review this edit.
|
| 141665586 | over 2 years ago | Thanks for fixing this area. Much appreciated.
|
| 141626786 | over 2 years ago | Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it looks good.
|
| 141625191 | over 2 years ago | Wow - I review a lot of edits in Washington State. You are the first to add airplane parking spots. Congrats. I'll send you more info on OSM in a message.
|
| 141580756 | over 2 years ago | #TIP: the school name nodes are redundant. The school grounds are already tagged with the names of the schools.
|
| 141572222 | over 2 years ago | #TIP: Is nice to leave a changeset comment. It might help you find one of your contributions later on.
|
| 141552178 | over 2 years ago | removed node - wrong address
|
| 141540537 | over 2 years ago | The county shows Southeast 1st street continuing as it was originally mapped. Can you confirm that it ends where you changed it to? Thanks - I'll send you some info on OSM in a message
|
| 141532716 | over 2 years ago | OSM was started in England so we use their tagging scheme. A path is would we would call a trail. A sidewalk is highway=footway. If the footway is alongside of a road, then we add the tag, footway=sidewalk.
|
| 141498744 | over 2 years ago | Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it looks good. I would probably leave the service=driveway off, just make it a highway=service.
|
| 141487278 | over 2 years ago | Some suggestions - save and upload your contributions before moving to a distant location. OSM doesn't use descriptive names. I've removed the names from the couple of buildings you added. Square buildings by just selecting the outline then type a "q" - a simple step to improve the look of the building.
|
| 141432657 | over 2 years ago | Happy to see another city GIS contribute to OSM. Let me know if you ever need help.
|