Hi Spellsaidwrong, Thanks for mapping this as public transport routes are really important to a lot of downstream users. With your edit, you appear to have added a new standalone relation not connected to the road network where it is best practice to add the relation to the actual road elements. I can revert the change set but it might be easier for you to add the relation to the roads and then remove your original line.

The other thing with importing data is that it needs to have the correct copyright AND have a waiver. Please check to see if this PTV dataset is available to import please. Keep up the excellent work
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146167821

Hi Redtree21, Thanks for adding this path. Just a really minor point, it would be great if you could connect this to Joseph Road so that routing engines can direct users.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146228886

Hi Redtree21, thanks so much for adding the Vline stops.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146229426

Excellent work on the bike path updates Sweeoon. I didn't even know about this route.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146202561

Love your work Melbourne Fan!
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146205196

Hi Hillster, Excellent work on the realignment!
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146211302

Hi Kieran, Thanks for the mapping. You appear to have altered railway=abandoned to railway=railway dismantled_soon_to_be_reopened however this will break a number of downstream maps. Please keep to the approved values that you can find in the OSM wiki before updating items on the map. All the best
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/137635857

Hi, the former railway is now a farm track and so the removal of highway = service is incorrect.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/146180153

Hi Cobba,
Thanks for mapping all the mines etc. The railway line has been removed and so is not "disused" but either razed or abandoned or road. I will be reverting this back to how it was set up previously. Very few branch railway lines in Victoria are disused. Most are well since abandoned.

Thanks Revnoplex for reactivating the bridge and surrounds which was on my to do list after hearing the good news earlier this week

Hi, thanks for the thoughts Cleary and I agree that any overall natural tag is not suitable for this or any other large relation of this size however I am please keep the KG area available for use by anyone interested in this area.

Hi, Alberton Road in Selby doesn't exist and it appears all land has abutting has been compulsory purchased in the past. The area of the road is not even walkable.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/66155113

Hi Woodpeck, I am somewhat disappointed by your comments. Does this include emergency HOTOSM tasks as well and can you provide a link to the distinction between both please? Happy to discuss offline. Regards

Hi, thank you for your input and details and I have fixed all three although I am not 100% sure about the last

Hi SB,
I have just removed the fixme query about Kumarl locality being located at this point you raised a long time ago. The road name, camp ground and this out of copyright map show the area around here but not 100% where the school was. Let me know if you want to re-instate the fix me. Thanks for all your mapping. https://nla.gov.au/nla.obj-234114826/view

Hi, that's a big area of changeset. Can I ask if you could provide a more intuitive changeset summary, rather than "Stuff" please?

Hi Fathima, welcome to OSM. A quick request to keep your change sets to small areas please. Most changesets should be to do with one area or one element. Also please consider detailing what changes you have made for what reasons please so other editors know what is going on. All the best and enjoy your editing.

Thanks Bob. These look like unauthorised tracks that have been removed a long time ago other than the short spur and are still available via the osm map and Strava. Going to cull them but agree with your approach as well. I was amazed at the area and the view from the top.

Sorry, these are
way/440744952
way/440744951
way/440744955
way/440744956
and
way/440744954

Most of these you marked as abandoned with another. Most had work done to prevent access from what I could see and the tracks pretty old.

Hi Bob, thanks for the updates around the Talbot on top of the Yarra BVLD. I intend to delete a number of trails that you have marked as abandoned as there really appears to be one key route and a walking path around the hill top reservoir. Are you ok with this?