DaveF's Comments

Changeset	When	Comment
112652755	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass is not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112650661	about 4 years ago	Hi Welcome to OSM landuse=grass is not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347 PS The name is certainly not how you tagged it. In the iD editor there's a way to ask for your edits to be reviewed, I recommend using it.
112603861	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass is not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112669333	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass is not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112615306	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass is not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112641601	about 4 years ago	Hi When using a function limited app, please be aware that many entities are already mapped as polygon ways. Please don't add duplicates as nodes
99118734	about 4 years ago	Hi node/8415492039 Is it really a manhole?
112560918	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass in not required for golf features. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112523699	about 4 years ago	PS if you want to check for gaps & overlaps: https://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeRelation?relationId=7606383&noCache=true
112523699	about 4 years ago	Thanks Are there signs for the path along the railway path section? I last looked for them a couple of years ago & never spotted any.
112553498	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112541321	about 4 years ago	leisure=golf_course Golf features have recently been included for rendering in OSM-carto which is considered the 'standard' map. They render as if assumed to be all grass, but adding that specific tag is useful, & should be added as 'surface'. surface=* Others for golf maybe 'artificial_turf' & matting. If using iD editor be sure to click the 'ignore' option to avoid it automatically adding it's 'landuse' suggestion.
112541321	about 4 years ago	Hi Welcome to OSM FYI landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112514866	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume a validator's suggestion is valid or correct. I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112534291	about 4 years ago	I've flagged it as an error: https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347
112534291	about 4 years ago	Hi landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence: landuse=grass The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass. To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used. golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch. The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface' leisure=pitch Please don't assume iD's validator suggestion is valid or correct.
112451060	about 4 years ago	Thanks
112451060	about 4 years ago	Hi You're the second person to mention this software. Are you using it? I don't know much about it. Is it just extracting golf data from OSM, or is it adding data & creating duplicates?
112523699	about 4 years ago	Hi Welcome to OSM. Is there a reason you created a new CFP relation & renamed the original to (b)? OSM has a policy of 'One feature, one OSM element': osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element Probably best if you transfer your recent additions over to the original relation.
97113115	about 4 years ago	OK. This is NOT how OSM works. The database is implemented to a certain standard. One of the accepted rules: osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element All data users have to abide by the standards & work to them. If there's a problem with their software then you need to contract them. Please correct your errors.