OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
97113115 about 4 years ago

No, there's conflicting items at each of the each of the markers in the OSMOSE link I sent.

Plus you've mapped this both as a driving range & a fairway:
way/893038683
way/893097825

Also check the buildings

97113115 about 4 years ago

I have a "big interest" in ensuring the quality of the OSM database.

Two bunkers, same tags, same location, overlaid, not the same id:
way/893097826
way/893038684

Could you please remove your duplicating data.

112451060 about 4 years ago

Hi
There is an error in iD's tagging & validation software, which I've flagged up:
https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347

At the moment it;'s a long winded process, but the defaults can be ignored by clicking a button.

I'm performing GB wide edits to correct all golf features.

112475601 about 4 years ago

Hi
It's disappointing how widespread this error by iD's developers has spread, & it will take a lot of effort to sort out.

Your English is much better than my French.

112475601 about 4 years ago

Hi
iD's validator is incorrect.
https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347

iD doesn't "automatically puts them back". It is a suggestion, which can, and should, be ignored.

Unsure what you mean in your second comment.

I didn't reverse your changeset, I swapped one tag for another. Any other edits remain.

97113115 about 4 years ago

No it's not. Unsure why you'd make such a claim.
Please remove duplicates.

97113115 about 4 years ago

Hi
You've added duplicate, overlaid golf features in Tewkesbury. Could you take a look & delete duplicates?

Click on a marker for an example:

http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/#zoom=15&lat=51.97926&lon=-2.16723&item=1230&level=1

90379689 about 4 years ago

Hi
I'm checking golf features.
http://osm.mapki.com/history/way.php?id=844062479

http://osm.mapki.com/history/way.php?id=844062480

Are these both bunkers & are they grass lined instead of sand?

112468712 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112475601 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112451060 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112453198 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112422806 about 4 years ago

Hi
I'm ahead of you.
https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8748#issuecomment-940155347

To me, Issue #2013 just highlights that iDs developers misunderstood tagging usage, as landuse=grass has never been used for sport pitches. I believe it's always been a primary tag, not a sub/adjective tag as iD were using it.

I'll follow up tomorrow.

Please add your own comments if you wish.

Sadly this isn't iDs only validator suggestion which oversteps the mark.

112392068 about 4 years ago

Hi
way/676133922

landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112422806 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112414832 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112421076 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112381802 about 4 years ago

Hi
landuse=grass in not required. It is for specific areas as indicated in the wikipage's first sentence:
landuse=grass

The landuse of golf features is 'golf' not grass.
To distinguish any differences the 'surface' tag should be used.

golf=* are a specific sport subset of leisure=pitch.
The tag to distinguish it's playing finish is 'surface'
leisure=pitch

Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112408403 about 4 years ago

Hi
Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.

112412691 about 4 years ago

Hi
Please don't assume a validator's *suggestion* is valid or correct.