Hi Aya from DigitalEgypt :-)

Thanks to contribute to OSM :-)

You modified a little my last contribution for the way/1385556562 by putting it on south of canal but the CNER reference system published here https://map.comptoir.net/maroc-reseau-routier-2025-01/ say the road is on north of canal.

Do you have a better source to confirm your change ?

I ask because I've done a script that check the matching between CNER ref and OSM, and if your source is better I have to tell my script to ignore this (your) change.

Thanks & cheers
Cyrille37

Hi.
Yes, it's wrong :-)
Corrected.

Thank you for your vigilance.

You're welcome :-)
Thanks & cheers

Hi Princess Aurora,

In the "2025-01 Morocco roads network update" a part's "ref" is changed from RR403 to RR309, what I did on changeset/165004956, but you canceled it in this changeset.

The "2025-01 Morocco roads network": https://map.comptoir.net/maroc-reseau-routier-2025-01/

Discussion : https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/morocco-maroc-reseau-routier-mise-a-jour-2025-01/128074/10

Best regards
Cyrille37.

Argh! I think I'm doing wrong. You've corrected my error :-P

I've checked with the Shapefile and You're right.

I'm very sorry for my previous comment.

Thanks & cheers
Cyrille37

Hi @salma_z

You've restored the ref "RP1514" but I'm not sure you source is up to date.

I've announced the Morocco road network update as 2025-01 in the introduction of page osm.wiki/Morocco/Roads
Also here https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/morocco-maroc-reseau-routier-mise-a-jour-2025-01 where we can talk if you want.

Thanks & cheers
Cyrille37.

Hi Nona

No problem :-)

Please let me know if you have any doubts or errors about my contributions, I made mistake too :-)

Regards & cheers
Cyrille37

Hi Nona Mostafa

Perhaps you've already seen the discussion about #digitalegypt conflict with Morocco Roads Network update from CNER data : osm.wiki/Talk:DigitalEgypt#Morocco_roads_network_2025_update

Please, don't remove new tag "ref" without checking the source at https://map.comptoir.net/maroc-reseau-routier-2025-01/

I'm open to talk if needed :-)
here : https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/morocco-maroc-reseau-routier-mise-a-jour-2025-01/128074

Thanks & cheers
Cyrille37.

Thank you Mohamed for your fast reaction :-)

I'm tagging Morocco roads netwok update changesets with #MA_RR_202501

Thanks & cheers
Cyrille37.

I've write a announce on the DigitalEgypt talk page : osm.wiki/Talk:DigitalEgypt#Morocco_roads_network_2025_update

Best regards
Cyrille37

Please, can you revert your change ? Or give me permission to revert ?

Hello Mohamed

The CNER published a Morocco Road Network via a announce in talk-ma@ mailing list.

I've put data here : https://map.comptoir.net/maroc-reseau-routier-2025-01/ with links to discussions.

For some days I'm updated the roads network, but it seems that you are reverting my contributions.

Do you have a better data source ?

We can talk about this update here : https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/morocco-maroc-reseau-routier-mise-a-jour-2025-01/128074

Best regards
Cyrille37.

Hello

Sorry, I'm updated some roads, but sometimes touching other that is not well, my apologies.

You can fix it please, or I'll do it in few days.

By the way, you can find the last CNER version of the Roads Network as Shapefile and PDF at osm.wiki/FR:Maroc#Sources_de_donn%C3%A9es

Thanks for your correction :-)

Regards
Cyrille37.

Thanks Aya, I will now prefix "ref" with the "R". Then I'll try to correct my previous changes.

By the way, the CNER gave me the Atlas, I put it on https://map.comptoir.net/maroc-reseau-routier-2025-01/ if it's of any use to you.

Hi Aya

I know the "R" was added around 2018, but the CNERR "Centre National d'Etudes et de Recherches Routières" don't use the "R" (N11, P3440...).
I think the "ref" attribute is a technical datum to link with official references.

So I've decided to don't remove the "R" for route relation, but remove it on ways.

I hope you understand my argument.

Thanks again
Cyrille37

Hi and thanks Aya Samir

I did the correction : changeset/164495879#map=19/33.147620/-6.078185

Thank you for your support :)

Please, subscribe to https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-ma list as the ingeenier from CNERR will answer you.

Also you can browse archives without subscribing to know more at https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ma/2025-March/thread.html

Cyrille37

Hi Aya Samir

I've made a resume here https://map.comptoir.net/maroc-reseau-routier-2025-01/ with the original Shapefile published on talk-ma and some splitted files for each route. Also you can find links to "discussions".

Thanks for checking my contributions, I can/should make some mistakes :-)

Cyrille37.

Salut. Oui, étrange que j'ai fait ça :-P
Tu peux corriger :-)
Merci

Bonjour @Kalepom

J'ai vérifié sur le terrain et il s'agit bien de la ville de Belgique Q1686757 pour la Rue de Jemmapes à Tours.

Je corrige...