OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
148837948 almost 2 years ago

Couple things:
1) Do not delete and readd. Just manipulate what is mapped to preserve edit history.
2) Do not "lollipop" landcovers to simulate holes. Multipolygon relations should be used instead.

I have resolved this for you for this changeset.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/148837948

148833262 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148833657

148833049 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148833244

148831638 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148832090

148830780 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148832087

148830138 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148830429

148829317 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148829830

148827482 almost 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted for the following reasons:
* Partial overlap of landcovers
* Removal of features to redraw them
* Many landcover areas split up to resemble multipoloygons, rather than creating multipolygons

I stongly advise you to read the following wiki section PRIOR to making further edits:
leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

changeset/148828349

148819327 almost 2 years ago

Do not partially overlap landcover features, especially ones with the same tags (fairway).
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/148819327

148821775 almost 2 years ago

Please do not use the live OSM servers to test features. A sandbox can be used in JOSM without pushing the info to the live database.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/148821775

148824796 almost 2 years ago

Why did you delete what is there just to redraw it (with errors, mind you)? It is best to manipulate what is already mapped to preserve edit history.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/148824796

148825557 almost 2 years ago

Why did you delete what is there just to redraw it (with errors, mind you)? It is best to manipulate what is already mapped to preserve edit history.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/148825557

148821449 almost 2 years ago

As previously mentioned in this changeset:
changeset/148365086

Do not partially overlap areas.

148826219 almost 2 years ago

Do not lollipop or fold areas back on themselves to create a "hole" in an area. Multipolygon relations should be used instead.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/148826219

146387664 almost 2 years ago

Railroads that no longer exist (and have been built upon with no railway hardware remaining (rails, signals, electrification, etc.)) should not be mapped on OSM. OpenHistoricalMaps should be used instead.

OSM is only for what currently exists, and as time goes on, things will change. But OSM should match the real world and not what it might have once been.

148421080 almost 2 years ago

What source did you use for the handicap and hole information?

116446503 almost 2 years ago

Descriptive names should not be used, particularly for the driving range.

148304187 almost 2 years ago

Do not use descriptive names. Please review:

leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

148646555 almost 2 years ago

Please review:

leisure=golf_course#:~:text=the%20building%20itself.-,Common%20mapping%20pitfalls,-Adding%20name%3D*

148304187 almost 2 years ago

Do not "lollipop" landcovers by folding them back against themselves.