Understood. Are we able to map "razed" and "abandoned" roadways and buildings? I would find them especially useful in knowing how the roadways and buildings have changed over time and how they have adjusted.

I give up on trying to update railways for what actually exists on the ground. If railway mappers want to keep outdated and long-gone features, that's fine. I would think that having a map that only has what is actually on the ground would be important. I apologize for trying to update outdated features to bring the map up to date to represent what is truly on the ground where no railways crossings exist across freeways and through people's living rooms.

I digress. I will not edit railways going forwards, and apologize.

This golf course does not exist anymore and it is now an entire residential neighborhood. It has been completely removed and overbuilt by houses, roads and other structures.

Features that no longer exist and have been overbuilt should not be mapped on OSM. A good place to put them would be on OpenHistoricalMap (OHM) though so that the history may be preserved.

Reverted in:
changeset/134908249

Is construction complete? It looks done on Mapbox Aerial Imagery?

Completely understood.

Thanks for that. I am definitely keeping it as nodes going forwards. Screw that headache - I don't want to do that again.

For reference, I duplicated the 'new' nodes, then deleted store info and merged it with the buildings to get that nyc node back.

Updated in:
changeset/134885099

Thanks and updated. Corrected in changeset: changeset/134884855
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/134840218

Thanks for the feedback and the education.

I have updated it in changeset:
changeset/134884833#map=15/40.7294/-73.9021
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/134840164

Is there a reason you don't connect the cartpaths over the waterways with a bridge? Would add a lot more details to the map.

Reverted in:
changeset/134793156

Additionally, golf course has gone out of business.

these buildings aren't even remotely square nor do they match aerial imagery. I have cleaned it up.

What source did you use for this "proposal"? I can't seem to verify it based on aerial imagery or ground truth.

Doesn't look like any construction has started yet, even 4 years later. Has construction begun? Are they even still planning to build it?

Generally, things aren't mapped even as a proposal until construction has started.

Is it still under construction? The GPS units are not able to route anywhere here since this is still marked as closed on OSM.

Generally, temporary road closures are not added on OSM, since it could continue to show up as closed even when OSM is corrected since most software is not live, and the data could easily be 6 months old or so.

Why did you set access=no on

way/108816441

Called out in note:
osm.org/edit?note=3631770

Still expected to be done in 2024? It doesn't look like construction has started in aerial imagery.

Buildings are extremely low quality and not squared. Reverted in part or in whole in changeset:

changeset/134398274

User was blocked for making similar edits:
osm.org/user_blocks/5531

Buildings are extremely low quality and not squared. Reverted in part or in whole in changeset:

changeset/134398207

User was blocked for making similar edits:
osm.org/user_blocks/5531

Buildings are extremely low quality and not squared. Reverted in part or in whole in changeset:

changeset/134398207

User was blocked for making similar edits:
osm.org/user_blocks/5531

Buildings are extremely low quality and not squared. Reverted in part or in whole in changeset:

changeset/134398207

User was blocked for making similar edits:
osm.org/user_blocks/5531

Buildings are extremely low quality and not squared. Reverted in part or in whole in changeset:

changeset/134398207

User was blocked for making similar edits:
osm.org/user_blocks/5531

Buildings are extremely low quality and not squared. Reverted in part or in whole in changeset:

changeset/134398207

User was blocked for making similar edits:
osm.org/user_blocks/5531