OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
154618732 over 1 year ago

I understand very well. You could change foot=permissive isntead, but there is no way right now to specify the danger level of a footpath. I wish there was, but it does not exist yet. Usually, we should use other data on top of osm for this kind of usage, but I know it is difficult to implement. However, you can add any tag you like and use them for your specific routing. Example: routing:danger=1-10 and then in your routing engine you could route only if danger <= 5 or so. But keep in mind this is non-standard and people could remove those unstandard tags. The problem here is that on a Sunday at 7AM, this crossing is almost always emty and thus very safe, but at rush hour on a weekday, this is dangerous, but still legal. Highway code explains that you must use a crosswalk if between two intersections, but at an intersection, you can cross, even if there is no paint or crosswalk as such, expcet if there is a specific sign for pedestrian saying it is illegal to cross the street there.

154618732 over 1 year ago

Unsafe but legal. Unfortunately, we need to keep them. Thanks!

154415385 over 1 year ago

Also, please use this offset when dealing with Montreal Bing 2020 aerial imagery: 0.6,-1.54

See this page: osm.wiki/Montr%C3%A9al under Bing Maps Offset

154415385 over 1 year ago

That's fine, but can you explain why you remove the connectivity with the taxiways?

153949145 over 1 year ago

The dental technician would be the person who build the implant. The denturist is the one who will install it in the patient mouth.

153949145 over 1 year ago

Honestly I don't know, but in french, the name of the places (Denturologiste) is translated to denturist, so this should be correct to use the speciality=denturist.

153944471 over 1 year ago

Please do not test in public open street map data. You may be flagged for vandalism. Reverting.

153949145 over 1 year ago

Denturologiste = Denturist
Dentiste = Dentist
Why remove the speciality?
Denturist != Dentist

153951480 over 1 year ago

Shouldn't we add informal paths there so the park is accessible from Rue des Paquerettes? Pedestrian would not make the detour through Moise-Vincent and Julien-Bouthillier to go to the park.

153869035 over 1 year ago

I fixed it. Thanks!

153869035 over 1 year ago

authorised personnel only would mean access=private, not no. foot=no would mean even employees would have no access.

153781809 over 1 year ago

Please verify that there are no missing crossings when changing to separate instead of both/left/right for sidewalks.
Some routing engines will add foot=no to these roads and if sidewalks are not correctly connected at each intersection, this could break routing or add unrealistic detours. Thanks!

153644286 over 1 year ago

Merci pour l'info. C'est bizarre qu'ils n'aient pas au moins connecté la nouvelle piste au viaduc de la rue Saint-Pierre en attendant. Ça doit être cause d'un terrain privé.

153644286 over 1 year ago

Il semble que la traverse de l'A30 sera construite dans une deuxième phase:
https://roussillon.ca/grands-projets/parachevement-de-la-route-verte/

153644286 over 1 year ago

Ils vont vraiment abandonner le petit bout qui manque? Où sera la fin de cette piste cyclable finalement? Merci si vous pouvez trouver l'info.

153587458 over 1 year ago

These are paths used for access and are legit if you want to route to a specific pitch. I will readd them back.

153437091 over 1 year ago

The cycling paths were already mapped on the road itself as cycleay:left/right = lane with related detailed tag for separation, marking, etc. When there is no permanent physical separation, the concensus is to map the cycling lane on the road itself. Flex posts are not permanent and are often removed in spring, fall and winter. I fixed it already. Thanks!

153344958 over 1 year ago

It is legal to cross the street as a pedestrian at Gladstone/Ste-Catherine, even if no official crossing is there. Removing it would force routing detours for pedestrians. Thanks!

148274172 over 1 year ago

L'historique est bien accessible ici, au besoin:
way/100809051/history

148274172 over 1 year ago

J'ai complété l'alignement pour la partie ouest du barrage: changeset/152756786