OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
120003006 over 3 years ago

What is the source this (way/1053636223) is from the Nature Conservancy?

120557252 over 3 years ago

Karson,

Please stop tagging these areas with `leisure=nature_reserve` such as you did in way/1057364174. As other mappers have already expressed, this is not the proper tagging for these undeveloped HOA areas (changeset/119868975). They should only be tagged with `lesiure=nature_reserve` if they are specifically protecting the wildlife, flora, fauna there there. If this is not the case, the area should be left untagged.

Regards,
BubbaJuice

62229848 over 3 years ago

Was this all traced by hand?

119868975 over 3 years ago

I'm retagging the neighborhood right now I would prefer no conflicts.

119866359 over 3 years ago

Hey karsonkevin2,

In what way is way/1052733252 a nature reserve?

Thanks,
BubbaJuice

119558671 over 3 years ago

See changeset/119646813. Someone asked the same question. (I'm assuming you're using some validator.)

119646813 over 3 years ago

I'm not sure if I do. By "monumentor" I mean the government agency that placed the benchmark there. From what I read on the wiki (I didn't totally understand it as it doesn't actually describe what it is) but it is for a protected feature. These are not really protected. If they're gone, they're gone, unless someone decides to reset it with a new disk (very unlikely). What the tag means is just what government agency had employees go out and set the benchmark.

119646813 over 3 years ago

Hey user_5359,
The meaning of the tag "monumentor" I have started using for benchmarks is which agency monumented the benchmark. In the case of "PUSCH", it was the USGS. The names are completely legitimate. I have visited all of these benchmarks personally and I added them to the database for a rendering proposal, osm.wiki/User:BubbaJuice/Survey_Points_Rendering, where you can find images of each of them, with their stamped names. The coordinates I have are from the NGS database, which is in the public domain as it is a government work.

119048272 over 3 years ago

Also deleting inaccurate building footprints.

118441211 over 3 years ago

On this house, multiple angles are missing: way/1039995323

On this house, a side of the house is angled which is not captured in the footprint: way/1039995319

On this house, there is a part of the house mapped that isn't even there (and never was): way/1039995343

And the list just goes on and on and on. I could nitpick at almost every single house here and find something wrong with it.

118441211 over 3 years ago

Hello abfkts,

It seems you have imported many Microsoft Building Footprints via RapiD. (Essentially an undiscussed import, but that's besides the point.) However, these are notorious for being inaccurate. Oro Valley has some very complicated buildings that can not be captured in exact detail using the footprints. My philosophy is to add valid, detailed data than no data at all and importing these buildings completely defies that. Unless you provide valid reasons as to why I should not revert all of your changesets adding buildings in this area, I will be reverting all of these buildings by 2 day from now. Please leave a comment saying that you have at least seen this message.

Thanks,
BubbaJuice

115405509 almost 4 years ago

Hi TCarp,

It seems you have traced already mapped fairways. These will be deleted. Please respond why you did this.

Thanks,
BubbaJuice

115878766 almost 4 years ago

Thanks. In particular, what is the source of the name of way/1013843427?

115878766 almost 4 years ago

What is the source of the names of these cemeteries?

117223770 almost 4 years ago

Source: USGS 3DEP

116262374 almost 4 years ago

Sources: Ersi World Imagery; Mapbox Satellite; USGS 3DEP; Bing aerial imagery

115019477 about 4 years ago

Hello aznative,

Thank you for your contributions to the database.

However, you have made a mistake in tagging all of the Tonto National Forest into a farmyard. This is incorrect because not all of the forest is a farmyard. A portion of it could be a farmyard but not the whole thing. This one separate portion would deserve its own way.

I will be changing its tagging back to before this changeset.

Thank you,
BubbaJuice

114860271 about 4 years ago

Noticed I forgot to add sources, here they are:

National Agricultural Imagery Program; Ersi World Imagery (Clarity); Maxar Premium Imagery; Ohio Statewide Imagery 1 ft

112720154 about 4 years ago

Hello Dylansc,

The Broadway Underpass should not be tagged as a tunnel. It should either be a bridge or a tunnel, not both. It is clear that Broadway cutts through the earth that Toole Avenue was set on but Toole Avenue clearly has a bridge over this cut through earth. Tunnels are normally enclosed also, this has a large gap in the middle of it separating the bridges of the railroad and Toole Avenue.

I will be changing this back to how it was.

Thank you,
BubbaJuice

114238156 about 4 years ago

Said iD changeset: changeset/114238402