Allison P's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 123288581 | over 3 years ago | name:en=Qanat is not correct, it is a description. Should just leave it blank. |
| 125632191 | over 3 years ago | Hello, fellow Allison! Please square buildings after drawing them by selecting them and pressing Q. Thanks! |
| 125632161 | over 3 years ago | Really, over 16,000 changesets and you're not squaring the buildings by selecting them and pressing Q? |
| 125632111 | over 3 years ago | The fairway should be a multipolygon with the green as an inner way. Let me know if you're not sure how to do this. You should just be able to select both ways and press C to merge them. |
| 125631991 | over 3 years ago | Check spelling of way/1090871622 "Avenur" |
| 125631933 | over 3 years ago | The green and bunker need to be cut out of the fairway; they should not have any overlap. |
| 125631916 | over 3 years ago | Please use better changeset comments. They are required for a reason; to help other mappers know what you are doing. Thank you. |
| 125631746 | over 3 years ago | Please make sure to square buildings by selecting them and pressing Q. Also, names should not be used as descriptions. It is fine (and in some of these cases proper) to not add a name. So things like "Coconut Plantation" and "Fagae'e Residential Area" need to go. Hope this helps. |
| 123298508 | over 3 years ago | The roads you added are residential, not service. Please fix them. |
| 124322026 | over 3 years ago | There are some questionable buildings like way/1086481246 and way/1086477520, but would be better for a response first. |
| 124157540 | over 3 years ago | And addr:street needs to match the street name exactly. So they shouldn't be all caps, and if the street name is still different then it needs to be fixed. |
| 125578480 | over 3 years ago | Please use better changeset comments. They are required for a reason. Users can be, and have been, blocked for not using them. |
| 125549122 | over 3 years ago | OSM is not for just any business listing. If there is no physical presence for your clients to go to, then this cannot be marked. I have removed it. |
| 124655329 | over 3 years ago | The data quality is not overall good. You may think it is, but multiple people believe otherwise. Not all of your arguments are insults, but they are all useless. Continuing to argue when I have probably said more than five times to cut it out is more rude than insulting. And we're not "doing whatever we want with [your] edits". Your edits violated the community's norms. If anyone else did this, they'd get a talking to. Perhaps the only difference is that they might actually listen. I'm not going to respond to you anymore, since you are incapable of either listening or arguing in good faith. If your next response is anything but an apology and a promise to not import anything without getting community approval, I'm going to the DWG. |
| 124655329 | over 3 years ago | No one was talking about humanitarian mapping. You're changing the subject for the sake of some particularly lame whataboutism. I agree that a lot of humanitarian mapping goes unreviewed and is often low quality, but I don't do that. I focus on helping people who are mapping their own areas because they can do things armchair mappers can't. It's quite hilarious to question the editing proficiency of someone who helped build the software you use to edit the map. I don't know why you still believe that you will change people's minds on this. You have so far driven no one else to your cause. All you've done is insult and belittle others, and to a pretty significant extent. Hand-traced buildings are never a waste of time. If done by a user with basic knowledge of the editor and OSM principles trying their best, they are always more accurate and precise than Bing. If you're so concerned about wasting time, this discussion seems like the best place to save some. |
| 54773314 | over 3 years ago | You can tag maxspeed:advisory instead. |
| 114105906 | over 3 years ago | Also, not all features need a name. "Foot Path" is just a description of the feature. The name should just be left blank. |
| 120137851 | over 3 years ago | I believe it is normal to tag the pharmacy in addition to the drug store. I've seen this many times. |
| 125480041 | over 3 years ago | Tough luck. There are no laws against mapping others' property where OSM is based. There is a law against computer vandalism, though. And there are plenty of users who are happy to restore the data as often as is needed. The other thing is that we're not responsible for misuse of maps using OSM data. Legally or logically. We can certainly take more steps to lower the chances of misuse (and are happy to, so long as this doesn't involve incorrect mapping), but the appropriate response is to put up physical warnings. We map military installations in countries where doing so is banned. Map making without permission of the Chinese government is also banned, but we do it anyway. Simply put, there's nothing you can do. I don't say this to be a jerk. People use my driveway all the time, leaving tire marks. I just know the map isn't at fault. People think they can use it as a turnaround or in one case avoid a road closure. They've done it since before OpenStreetMap had my driveway. If I really needed to take action, I'd put "no trespassing" signs up. |
| 125478951 | over 3 years ago | Before uploading, please square buildings by selecting them and pressing Q. |