Definitely not.

Is it really spelled with an extra space as "West Moreland" over "Westmoreland"? way/1071778840

The footprint wasn't 100% accurate, being slightly rotated off. They didn't preserve the history, instead submitting the edit across two changesets.

This could be a consequence of mapping for OSM Streak. I have not used it but I think it may require users to add a new feature, not just improve an existing one. A shame, really, because there are still a lot of new buildings in the area that haven't been mapped yet.

It's all manual, it's just really low quality.

This user never responds to changeset comments and has already been blocked twice for it.

I drove by Linder and State today. The only physical barrier is to the south.

name=* is not for descriptions. node/6705147488 should be tagged as religion=christian and perhaps a fixme requesting the name.

Please check the case of addr:state. It should be all caps.

Check addr:state on way/444328100.

addr:state=ID?https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4710892055/history

I would have to ask the same about Linder and State.

Is the road really physically divided at way/1085450147? I see a short island. It should only be represented with two ways for the length where the island is present.

Also, you should not add horse=* access to roads in Ada County. There are no signs posted anywhere because horses are not used for transportation here.

All incorporated municipalities in Idaho are cities. This does not mean they are marked as a place=city, which is for places with a high population and/or major amenities like an airport.

Check spelling of "cemetery" too.

Make sure to expand all suffixes (Court over Ct.)

addr:state is for postal abbreviations. Use ID over Idaho. Thanks!

Soda Springs is not a city. I don't think it's even really a town. Please revert the classification change.

Also the room numbers are not names. Should be addr:room.

That sounds like an error on their site. It might help to reach out to them. Keep in mind that what's on the ground is generally what's mapped. If there's no trace on the ground then Ross Playground may just be an official_name.

Test edits should be done on the dev server, not here.