OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
82780581 over 5 years ago

Persiaran Sultan Abdul Hamid was reclassified. There are so many schools and banks next to this road, so I would assume the traffic is more significant.

82531429 over 5 years ago

Hello!

ref=1 route across Kuala Lumpur is tricky. It may not be displayed on street and direction signs.

If your ground truth team managed to follow the trails, then it's a win-win.

However, if ref=1 is from extrapolation, then hopefully, please do not "map" it.

82437706 over 5 years ago

Hi!

I would consider this as one carriageway (osm.wiki/Highways#Carriageways) - non-separable roadway.

https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/Xsiz5guHBPSQLzAHskQtf4

Further northeast where there is a physical barrier, I'll usually map those as separate highways.

82516872 over 5 years ago

Boleh beritahu sumber data?

80191410 almost 6 years ago

Salam, kenapa way way/767505062 ini telah un-glue?

Semak https://nrenner.github.io/achavi/?changeset=80191410

82409528 almost 6 years ago

GlobalLogic bad edits were also refined, at least from a local's POV, rather than blindly tracing off satellite imagery. The cleanup is still ongoing, because there's no use to actually contacting their team members which probably I reckoned, already done with OpenStreetMap (been inactive for months).

Sorry remote mappers, but never assume there's no one to map around here from ground truth. Please just, or else, talk to DWG.

81146128 almost 6 years ago

It's really common to have highways, this type as one goes further inland, away from denser populated places. My practice is usually map them (see pictures) as highway=unclassified.

81146128 almost 6 years ago

Please also check thoroughly other highways that overwrote my ground truth edits made in December 2019

81146128 almost 6 years ago

way/773675133/history

Compare against my picture https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Simpang_tiga_Jalan_Kampung_Paya_Lipai.jpg

81146128 almost 6 years ago

Hi

way/319422336/history

Compare against my picture osm.wiki/File:Ground_truth_somewhere_in_Pendang_Kedah_Malaysia.jpg

taken somewhere around osm.org/go/4GrAcRQkx-?m=, but on the same way.

I have mapped it as a highway=unclassified because, uh, I've been there?

81091388 almost 6 years ago

Care to explain why these tags are removed?

node/1813724314/history

27633417 almost 6 years ago

Hi.

Don't really mind - this area is sparsely populated, although the K509 route may act as a more significant feeder route towards the Pendang town. I may inclined to tag it as a secondary road but tagging it as a tertiary road may not totally be completely incorrect.

In this Pendang district, inconsistent tagging may be due to independent remote mapping done by different individuals.

81258881 almost 6 years ago

Yes, please.

I understand your way of seeing it, but across this state (Kedah - where I'm from), there would be some extensions just like this. Usually due to the presence of a nearby school. E.g. way/370743006/history just adjacent to this particular highway.

The highways would somehow built to serve two-way traffic with two lanes.

The unclassified way adjoining it is built differently (in physical properties e.g. how they're built) as well.

81258881 almost 6 years ago

*sorry, highway=unclassified

81258881 almost 6 years ago

Hi, this way, I had surveyed it (check way history), and to my ground truth, it is way more closer to highway=tertiary rather than highway=secondary

way/319422331/history

79374289 almost 6 years ago

Sorry, wrong changeset - I've should've left it over this instead: changeset/79829317

79829317 almost 6 years ago

See discussion on changeset/79374289

79374289 almost 6 years ago

Hi!

Please check way/754650224/history

I've ground truth-ed the surrounding areas on early December 2019 - check changeset/78274807

80881796 almost 6 years ago

https://cf.mastohost.com/v1/AUTH_91eb37814936490c95da7b85993cc2ff/enosmtown/media_attachments/files/000/083/273/original/039fc9990515737c.png

80881796 almost 6 years ago

Untuk

way/626647088

Silahkan semak dengan GPS tracks yang diupload ke OSM