OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
72759685 over 6 years ago

This issue might also affect every potential highways which have been mapped as highway=unclassified or highway=residential.

Please, hopefully your team's edits are re-reviewed.

72759685 over 6 years ago

I would like to draw attention to your mapping team: be extra careful to map potential highways in this area with paddy fields surrounding it.

For example, this highway (way/708427243) was mapped as an unclassified highway.

I drive around this area a few times a month. Usually highways adjacent to canals are merely dirt track for agricultural purposes. It may appear quite prominent, e.g. http://osmz.ru/imagery/#17/5.87901/100.44482/mp (from the imagery) but please, please take extra care.

I hope your team would begin fix this issue. Please let me know when it's completed.

18758847 over 6 years ago

Go ahead and fine tune these ways (way/245017827, way/245017847)

19846101 over 6 years ago

Go ahead making adjustments for it

33976786 over 6 years ago

way/370289700 (way/370289700) is manually surveyed by me back in 2015 (check history in JOSM by CTRL+H).

It might appear as a paved residential highway, but usually it might not be the case. This highway is next to a canal, and from imagery, this highway serves only a few houses to its western end of this highway.

I might upgrade the highway from its western end, up to node/3739997555 (node/3739997555) as a highway=service.

Beyond that node, I've considered it should be left untouched.

32066048 over 6 years ago

Fair enough. way/288251424 (way/288251424) could be tagged as highway=service

55919468 over 6 years ago

way/557212832 (way/557212832) could be an alley (service=alley) instead.

It's a quite narrow highway passing through some houses which do not belong in a planned housing estate e.g. the one just laying south of these houses.

http://osmz.ru/imagery/#19/6.17116/100.36885/mp

51057897 over 6 years ago

Fair enough, please make appropriate adjustments for only these highways

54242327 over 6 years ago

Consider using access tags to indicate no through traffic.

access=*

72584053 over 6 years ago

Please make amendment for this way: way/706856742

From my daily commute, this stretch of highway is barely navigable by cars. It is close to a track rather than a residential highway.

70847530 over 6 years ago

These (way/160693842, way/287331641 and way/287331661) are collector highways. I've been there very recently (June 2019).

58189596 over 6 years ago

The way (way/333017415) beyond the particular node (node/3401317887) is mapped as unclassified highway because it has higher hierarchy - it carries more traffic in and out across this village.

Source - I'm a local mapper

29014635 over 6 years ago

The way way/329614444 may act as a collector road from node/6639581545 to the adjacent unclassified highway.

From the same node to node/6639581541, the highway might serve as a driveway (highway=service, service=driveway) because it only leads to a house.

I've cycled through this area myself back in February 2015 (refer changeset date).

55227881 over 6 years ago

way/493408183 and way/551373827 may act as collector roads for the adjacent villages.

Please do not change them.

20797117 over 6 years ago

Fair enough, please adjust them accordingly

36843652 over 6 years ago

way/394165932
way/394165965
way/394165931
way/394165955

36843652 over 6 years ago

I will amend the boundary of the residential area (way/318224761) later. There are only a few houses in the area, but obviously the retail buildings next to the major highway dominates the landuse (retail).

The details of the highways of this area may be left untouched as they are.

60314637 over 6 years ago

Unfortunately I may have not uploaded my own collection of GPS tracks to map details like this, but hopefully your team gets what I'm trying to convey the message.

60314637 over 6 years ago

I'm a local, active mapper around this place (Alor Setar town and its surroundings) - so you have my word.

way/603932790
way/603932791

Please check the edit dates too. Bing imagery across the city dates from 2014. Maxar imageries (which can also be found in Esri World Imagery) could be from 2017.

24581657 over 6 years ago

Feel free to downgrade them as residential highways