OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
65643990 about 7 years ago

Many thanks for your response and actions.

I'm not going to be a gatekeeper in my home state - Kedah, except the Langkawi Island (relation/4444908); but I've been contributing through ground truth. Seeing things with my surveys.

I salute your team's work on adding unmapped roads through remote mapping. Not everybody has the time doing that, including myself.

Hopefully your team might take extra precautions - not overwriting someone else's effort in order to put more things on the map.

Since your team is editing with JOSM, take some time to inspect history of road geometries (Ctrl + H). If it's quite recently mapped (e.g. probably up to 2 years ago by an active local mapper), just try contacting those related users to get an idea why and to inform that changes would be made (and state the reason why).

65643990 about 7 years ago

Hello there.

This particular way: way/482514619/history

I have surveyed there by myself last year. See history. It's actually closer to an unclassified road, rather than a residential road.

65629304 about 7 years ago

Hello! I don't think this particular stretch of this highway (way/236001234) has a speed limit of 30 km/h.

65538173 about 7 years ago

alt_name can handle that if you want.

alt_name = Kawasan Rehat dan Rawat XYZ; Kawasan Rehat dan Rawat XYZ Arah Utara / Selatan

That semicolon (;) is necessary to add another name.

If you also feel like doing it, include

short_name = R&R XYZ

(R&R is visible even from the signboards)

In real life, if you travel northwards, you won't go to the services on the opposite side of the journey.

65538173 about 7 years ago

Because that's what they say on signboards - on the ground rule (osm.wiki/Disputes#On_the_Ground_Rule).

You can still name those as Kawasan Rehat & Rawat on alt_name tag

65538173 about 7 years ago

For all R&Rs across PLUS:

Aren't they always "Kawasan Rehat"? Not "Kawasan Rehat & Rawat"?

See:

https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/k4bKMenwfEQWqOBdcYiurw

https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/qBCaHFwCjokYF4sxRtUgXw

64475073 about 7 years ago

Kawasan macam ni... garden.

Cuba bayang, leisure=park ni tempat tumpuan orang ramai datang bila-bila masa

leisure=garden

64475133 about 7 years ago

Grassland ni senang cakap, macam tempat lembu ragut rumput. Rumput panjang-panjang.

natural=grassland

64436131 about 7 years ago

Memang sistem tag ni nampak tak jelas, kadang-kadang kena belek

landuse=*

atau

leisure=*

63566226 about 7 years ago

Okay dah rasanya... check yang lain jugak ye.

64038784 about 7 years ago

Kalau sekadar tempat lapang... petang-petang orang datang main, boleh kira recreation ground.

leisure=park kalau ada macam-macam, contohnya ada taman permainan sekali dengan lorong joging, court takraw/badminton, ada bangku, dan macam-macam.

64394473 about 7 years ago

Boleh consider "semak" jugak bagi tempat yang takde kebun.

natural=scrub

64436131 about 7 years ago

No problem, betulkan apa yang boleh. Kiteorang tak makan orang eh :)

Cuma harap petakan betul-betul je.

64404516 about 7 years ago

*sorry, it should be Mapillary photo streams taken at street level

64404516 about 7 years ago

Many thanks for your prompt response.

Please also use Mapillary imagery that might be available for some places, so that your team have an idea what all of you are looking at.

64225047 about 7 years ago

Can you please check for your error: way/488381471/history

A landuse has been turned into a highway? I've personally been there myself last year, it's not a highway that huge.

64404516 about 7 years ago

Also, check for error for this one: way/638477904

A residential landuse has turned into a highway.

64404516 about 7 years ago

Hi, you might re-consider Jalan Pekan Darat (way/45982999) as not a residential highway.

This Mapillary photo stream suggests otherwise (of higher hierarchy) https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/_ZtRsvgBvzt0DY-W3ReU4w

64436131 about 7 years ago

Padang bola guna leisure=pitch

leisure=pitch

64394473 about 7 years ago

landuse=farmland sesuai untuk petak-petak sawah...

landuse=farmland