Because it's an incomplete (open) relation as well, if it's not me, then those who do QA will remove this in the near future. I have to remove this for now. Don't worry, there's a tool to undelete this.

Don't forget, it's for Pendang district as well. Just leave it blank for the time being.

Duplikasi way/146655070. Edit Anda sudah didelete: changeset/47561964

Maaf, bukan unduh, sudah dihapus.

Maaf, sudah ada yang ini: way/144292569

Edit Anda sudah diunduh: changeset/47561890

Silly me. This time adding data, not reverting vandalism.

What kind of stuff? 😏

I will stick to something simple and official. Which place got Majlis Bandaraya, and which place not have Majlis Bandaraya - got only Majlis Perbandaran.

Even Sungai Petani is under Majlis Perbandaran Sungai Petani, not Majlis Bandaraya Sungai Petani. It's official, Sungai Petani is only place=town, not place=city.

Come and discuss in the forum. Open new table, discuss.

Thanks for your edit. However, "Selamat Datang" is definitely "Welcome" in the Malay language. It's okay, later I will remove the name but not the place.

Always remember that we tag data because that's simply it is in real life, not how we are going to show on the map --->

Kangar is special case, but common knowledge says it is the capital of Perlis. Regardless its status as place=city or place=town, other tag can definitely help saying that Kangar is the capital of Perlis.

If consider your standard, then we have 39 (12+12+12+3) cities across Malaysia. I think better we stick to what's official and easier and clearer: which place got Majlis Bandaraya (that's definitely a city) and which got simply Majlis Perbandaran.

In fact, the Wikipedia article explicitly mention Muar is a town.

Whoops, local governing entity or Pihak Berkuasa Tempatan.

I see what you are trying to say. Muar is the royal city of Johor (Bandar Maharani), but Majlis Perbandaran Muar is the "governing local entity" (PBT), not Majlis Bandaraya Muar. See http://www.mpmuar.gov.my/

Definitely needs GPS traces over here to confirm its geometry

Maaf, lambat reply. Sila rujuk perkara kedua dalam perincian osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only.

Tak dinafikan, ada nama masjid yang sama di dua tiga tempat berlainan, kalau tak silap, tag alamat (rujuk http://i.imgur.com/7kxdvR2.png?1) boleh jadi ganti.

Kalau tag addr:city dirasakan kurang tepat, gunakan tag addr:place (http://i.imgur.com/NjKATq8.png?1)

Apa-apa janganlah segan-segan hantar mesej.

Okay. Next time be sure to put changeset comment, something like "border created from approximation based on local knowledge". This is useful for other mappers and/or OSM big boss (Data Working Group). Who knows.

Sila isi nama bangunan sahaja dalam tag name=*. Tidak perlu ditambah nama tempat, melainkan ditulis sedemikian di papan tanda bangunan tersebut. Nama tempat boleh diisi dalam tag alamat, osm.wiki/Tag:addr:*=. Contohnya name=Masjid Al-Husna, Bandar Sunway dan name=SJK (C) Yuk Chyun, Petaling Jaya seharusnya sekadar name=Masjid Al-Husna name=SJK (C) Yuk Chyun sahaja.

---

A place name in the name=* tag may be unneccessary, unless a particular building says so. The rest can be described using tags pertaining to addresses. For example, name=Masjid Al-Husna and name=SJK (C) Yuk Chyun is more preferable. The place name could be put into addr:place=* or addr:city=*

Read more addr=*

What source of data you're using to create this border?