OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
67887265 almost 7 years ago

Hey Danny,
For consistency sake, let's agree on how to map sidewalks when they meet the road.
I think it makes sense to draw a separate crossing way (highway=footway, footway=crossing) on crossings with all-way stops and traffic signals. Otherwise, just connect sidewalk to the road with lower priority.
BTW, if you see missing stop signs/traffic signals - feel free to add them.

67807004 almost 7 years ago

Do you mind not deleting an actual existing-on-the-ground disused rail tracks in favor of a proposed railway that is still 5+ years away and that might not even be funded? At least until the tracks are ripped out?
Please re-map it.
Thanks.

67640146 almost 7 years ago

http://data.ottawa.ca/dataset/licensed-child-care-centres

67670536 almost 7 years ago

Sounds good. I'll leave these to you.
One more thing, I recommend to apply "Building with almost square angles" fix to the buildings you import.
See here for more info: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca/2019-February/009101.html

Otherwise inevitably OSM police from Europe will show up and question your work.

67640146 almost 7 years ago

OK, I'll keep that in mind.

67640146 almost 7 years ago

Thanks. I see now it's pretty dirty indeed. Should've gone the task manager way.
Feel free to revert it if it's too much of a trouble, I'll create the TM project instead.

67640146 almost 7 years ago

Matt, do you have a list of problems so I can go through them?

Danny, I've been importing minor city datasets for a while with local buy-in. Imported this one by extension. If you have concerns let me know.

67234991 almost 7 years ago

Are you sure there are no addresses between 236 and 248 on Paseo private? How do they name their units? ABCD?

66885386 almost 7 years ago

Yeah I mean house numbers 1275, 1279, 1283, etc are not there. If they ever show up no one will be able to find them. That's what interpolations are for.

66885386 almost 7 years ago

Hey Brandon,
Great job adding addresses to buildings in Oshawa. One little thing though, consider NOT deleting address interpolations when there are missing house numbers on a street.
For example if there is ever house number 1275 on this street (somebody builds a duplex for example) nobody will be able to find it without interpolation you've deleted: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/66885386
Also it appears you are forgetting sometimes to add `addr:street` tags to buildings - those are needed

66338571 almost 7 years ago

SimonPoole: When an existing building has any meaningful tags I always replace geometry preserving history and existing tags. It's only when I encounter a cluster of `building=yes` without any other tags I would delete them.

66338571 almost 7 years ago

It's a high quality dataset from the city and it's square when the building is square and not square when the building is not square.

PS: love your tools and use them all the time, thanks.

66059780 almost 7 years ago

Yeah good point. I missed that rule at first and kept dragging for a while. Will switch to import account going forward.

65489620 almost 7 years ago

I've never seen "highway=destroyed:path" used before. Taginfo doesn't know about it either: https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/highway=destroyed:path

The tag you are looking for is "smoothness=impassable". Or you can use "access=no" although I would just use impassable.

65276201 about 7 years ago

Please pay attention to your edits. Both your changesets in Ottawa make no sense

64660575 about 7 years ago

Hi Hans, I've noticed you've added some bike lanes as separate ways along Fisher. This is not how they should be mapped. Separate ways should only be used for separate infrastructure, which painted bike lanes or shoulders are not, as you know.
Mapping cycle tracks along Prince of Wales as separated ways is correct. Bike lanes along Cayman and Fisher - NOT. I've removed them.
For painted bike lanes you should use tags on the road, i.e. cycleway=shoulder on Fisher or cyclway=lane on Grand Cayman.
Here's more details on our wiki: https://github.com/BikeOttawa/OSM-Bike-Ottawa-Tagging-Guide

64183892 about 7 years ago

I use osmcha to see what's going on around Ottawa. Helps reverse some bad changes by new mappers. Your changeset was flagged as suspect.

64183892 about 7 years ago

Seems like "leisure=dance" & "dance:teaching=yes" is more appropriate for dancing schools: leisure=dance
I wouldn't call dancing a sport.
Another option is using "amenity=dancing_school" but it appears to be abandoned in favour of "leisure=dance": amenity=dancing_school

63984506 about 7 years ago

Hi Heather,

Avoid tagging footways with footway=sidewalk like this one: way/167701739

Our routing algorithm excludes sidewalks, so it's kinda important. Sidewalks run right next to the streets, usually narrow and concrete.

63960393 about 7 years ago

Yeah it moved. Fixed