Reverted,, along with previous changesets, in changeset/166969310

Reverted in changeset/166968657

Resolved by changeset/118271038

Resoled by changeset/116785079

Hello,

Thank you for your contribution to the mapping of East Jerusalem, and in general!

In this changeset you have added layer=1 to two building multipolygons:
relation/3864691
relation/3864556

I assume this was in order to resolve overlap with their entrance footways:
way/257617650
way/257617671
way/1078708047

my understanding of the wiki page on
covered covered=*
and layer layer=*#Guidelines is that it would be better to add covered=yes to these ways rather that adding layer=1 to the entire building multipolygon.

Best regards,
zstadler

I was unable to find a relevant tagging in the wiki. I suggest you ask in the tagging questions forum.

A resort should also "provide housing accommodations for customers".
According to their website, this not the case here.

I have not created this node or the relation. This changeset is just about moving the node from an incorrect location.

Please feel free to add it to the appropriate relation.

Hello sderkach,

I see that you have not been an active OSM mapper for a few years. I would appreciate it if you take the time to respond to this message.

In 20 changesets, starting with this one, you have added a "tracktype=grade5" to tracks in Israel.

The Israel wiki page says that such a tag should be used for "Unpaved road requiring a locking differential and high clearance".

Have you been aware of that?

Thank you in advance,
zstadler

שלום PrimmCourier,

ברוך השב אל קהילת הממפים הפעילים!

מיפוי של שערים סגורים הוא מאד חשוב למטיילים. שער אחד מאלו שמיפית נמצא על הצומת, ולכן לא ברור את מי משלושת הדרכים שנפגשות שם הוא חוסם.
node/12844661776

תוכל בבקשה לתקן את המיפוי ולמקם את השער על אחת הדרכים ולא בצומת עצמו?

הסבר מפורט אפשר לראות בדף הוויקי על מחסומים
barrier=*#How_to_map_barrier_nodes

תודה על תרומתך למיפוי ב OSM ועל התיקון!

Please note that the HOTOSM project "Galilee, Israel: Mapping Buildings (Shefaram)" is #hotosm-project-19740
located at https://tasks.hotosm.org/projects/19740 and not #hotosm-project-19839 that was used to launch this edit.

#hotosm-project-19839 is "Galilee, Israel: Updating Land Use (Shefaram)"

Hello Nirzo,

Thank you for your contributions to the OSM mapping!

In this edit, the node node/12741644732 was added as a member of the Iron singletrack.

I believe this was by mistake, because MTB route relations are expected to have only ways.

If that's not a mistake, please describe what you wanted to map, and I'll try to find the OSM way to do that.

Thanks!

Hi,

Do you remember why you changed these nodes from suburb to hamlet?
Hamlet is supposed to be an isolated settlement.

Further information:

A few months after this edit, another user added way/1303446953as a replacement for the deleted way/1234277959 way/1234298083.

Then, 3 months ago, in changeset/162577061 user yanivzelig created relation/18713626 and used the replacement way/1303446953 as one of its members, effectively confirming the existence of that path.

As a result of the above, and the existence of recent GPS traces, I have reverted this changeset and the replacement ways that it caused.

Hello yanivzelig,

Thank you for your contributions to OSM!

In this edit you have deleted several paths including paths that have clear OSM traces:
367682058, 1234277959, 1234298083

Some of the traced were uploaded to OSM after this edit deleted the paths.

You have also ignored all changeset comments you have ever received for more than a year and a half.

Please respond to this comment and the other comments shown in this page:

: https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=2013202

Without your responses, it is possible that your contributions will be reverted.

אפשרות נוספת שאני מעדיף היא ערוץ הטלגרם של הממפים בישראל
https://t.me/OSM_Israel

זהו ערוץ פחות רשמי עם פחות חשיפה
למשתמשים עולמיים.
הערוץ נפתח כין השאר על מנת לספק תמיכה לממפים

שלום יניב,

תודה על תרומתך למיפוי ב OSM!

אני תוהה מה מקור התגית
colour=black?

בצילומים שבאתר קקל
https://www.kkl.org.il/research_and_development_projects/projects-center/yokneam-forest-promanade.aspx
לא נראים שלטי הכוונה בשחור

Hello Yuval,

Could you clarify the goals of this edit?
In what sense are the circles you created "better" than the original shapes, that were probably derived from satellite imagery?

תודה על הכוונה הטובה!
נשמח אם תמשיכי לעדכן את המפה במקומות שאת רואה חוסרים או אי-דיוקים.

העובדות הידועות לי כנראה ידועות גם לך, רותם:
- "שביל מגידו" שמופיע ב OSM מחליף את
"שביל רמות מנשה" המקורי שבוטל.
- חלק ניכר מהסימונים בשטח של שביל רמות מנשה נעלמו עוד לפני הסימון של שביל מגידו והשאר ממשיכים להעלם.
- על פי דיווחים של מטיילים לא ניתן יותר לטייל בשביל רמות מנשה על פי הסימונים שבשטח.

המיפוי ב OSM נועד לתאר את העובדות בשטח ולא לשמר עצמים או אירועים היסטוריים. ראי
- Map what's on the ground
- Don't map historic events and historic features
בוויקי של OSM
osm.wiki/Good_practice#Map_what's_on_the_ground