Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

Vandal changeset reverted

This changeset was reverted

This changeset was reverted

Hello milsh,

Please join this discussion.

Unless you respond in the discussion in the next 24 hours, I'm planning to undo ("revert" in OSM terminology) your last two edits: the edits that mainly deleted trails and roads in military practice areas and nature reserves.

Best regards,
Zeev

Note: the discussion continues in changeset/155275435

Hello Milsh,

Welcome to OSM!
I understand you meant to do good, but OSM has other ways to do things. Until we clarify things, please avoid any further such edits.

In short:
- If a road exists on the ground, it can, and should appear in OSM.
- Any access restrictions should be made on the tags.
- Mappers are expected to follow OSM global guidelines and local mapping conventions
- Mappers should be careful not to delete or damage mapping efforts of other mappers. When in doubt, ask the other mapper or the community.

Specifically for Israel:
- Such roads and trails are also shown in maps published by the Israeli government
- Entering military practice areas is allowed with proper permits provided by the military authorities.
- Similar permits may also given for Nature reserves.
- The norm in Israel is to avoid massive tagging of roads and trails in nature reserves and practice zones with access tags.

For further information and clarifications, in Hebrew or English, please join the OSM Israel Telegram channel https://t.me/OSM_Israel

Thank you,
Zeev

Hello culbi,
For a better explanation of the reasons for not copying from Govmap, and what can be done to allow that, please read this entry in the Legal FAQ:

osm.wiki/Legal_FAQ#XYZ_Organisation_has_data_for_free_download_under_licence_N._Can_I_use_it_in_OSM?

Among other things, it clearly says:
> Do not rely on your own legal interpretation of the licence.

Thanks,
Zeev

גם אני לא מוצא הכרזה על שמורת הר נזר. למעשה, הר נזר היה חלק מההכרזה הראשונה של "שמורת טבע שחלבים במנרה", כפי שניתן לראות בתשרית התוכנית:
https://mavat.iplan.gov.il/SV4/1/2087306/310
אני מנסה לברר מהו מקור הפיצול באתר iNature

נראה לי ש"שמורת טבע שחלבים במנרה" ו"שמורת הר נזר" הן שמורות נפרדות

ההרחבה של שמורת הר נזר, ממערב לכביש 886 היא פוליגון נפרד ולכן יש שם צורך ביחס

"שמורת טבע שחלבים במנרה" יכולה להשאר על הקו שלה -
way/1123124562

Please feel free to do that. I cannot help much.

:-)
לא התכוונתי שתבטל
התכוונתי לרמוז שתתאפק בפעם הבאה

ההכרזה פורסמה ב 23.7.24 ותכנס לתוקף רק 60 יום אח"כ

חשבתי שזה מיקום האריה השואג, אבל כנראה שזה לא.

את האריה השואג אפשר לתייג כ
historic=memorial
או
historic=monument