OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
111333241 about 4 years ago

Hi, you added duplicate cicleway on HaNetzah street. I already defined it lont time ago as a cycleway:left=track on the road itself.

111165723 over 4 years ago

Interesting idea! Will definitely do!
I still want to keep the "master" relation to easier find all child relations, mostly for management.

111107995 over 4 years ago

hello and welcome!
small correction: name tag should always have text in area local language. Other languages should be added as name:en, name:he,.. tags.
I fixed tags on Bet Gavriel: way/914243780
Also, it's better to not spread edits over long distances, you can commit changes any time you want, don't forget to write meaningful explanation of the change to help other mappers to understand your change.

110037362 over 4 years ago

Hi, may I ask why you removed wikipedia tag and added same wiki link as a website?

91837487 over 4 years ago

Hi, osm has a rule about roundabouts naming: they should be named only if have dedicated name sign, and should not inherit connected roads names.
See junction=roundabout

104764615 over 4 years ago

Hi, here you renamed very small part of Bat Galim Promenade to Arie Gurel. Can you comfirm that only this (way/35010792) small part was renamed or whole promenade had its name changed?

Also, please use more meaningfull comments for changesets and add sources, this will help other mappers.

92030463 over 4 years ago

Hi and welcome, small note: when you add name tag please put local name used by most civilians in the area in the "name" tag, and other languages in the name:he, name:en, etc. If you can't fill the local name, just add only relevant name:* tag and other mappers will complete.

110409705 over 4 years ago

I never saw a rule in OSM which disallows tertiary road to have a dead end.
In any case, there is no a dead end but a proper u-turn.
Additionally, other maps like https://www.govmap.gov.il/?c=185800,659691.48&z=6 do define this appendix with same class as whole street (you can tell this by the fact it's still rendered on a high zoom)

98035298 over 4 years ago

With all due respect, I was here recently and uploaded Mapillary images - this specific crossing is long time not exists (https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=822730465079077).
Please recheck your sources and avoid using old Bing imagery without local knowledge.
There are plenty fresh images on Mapillary and Kartaview.

96006011 over 4 years ago

If you saw it, then I don't understand why you lowered class of links. For example way/34906126 connects motorway with trunk and should be motorway_link. This changeset is pretty old and might be problematic to revert, please undo road class changes if you agree, and if you sure it's better this way - please come to our forum to discuss (https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=17256)

107735140 over 4 years ago

aerial photos are usually very old, I'd not advise using them without local knowledge

107735140 over 4 years ago

Hi, you added drain 2 months ago (way/963123748), I just was here and did not saw anything similar. What was your source?

110409705 over 4 years ago

Hello, may I ask why you downgraded Ben Gurion Avenue from tertiary to residental?

109690433 over 4 years ago

Nice, good to know! Thanks!

96006011 over 4 years ago

Hi,
looks like you wrongly changed many types of link roads. Current practice is to select higher class of two connected roads (except service roads).
Please see this document: osm.wiki/Link_roads_between_different_highways_types
and revert your changes.
Also in general - all major road types are already well defined and should not be touched if not redefined by transportation ministry.
If you wish to discuss something or have a question, you are welcome to our forum or telegram channel: https://t.me/OSM_Israel

109690433 over 4 years ago

why unofficial type=construction:route and not
type=construction
construction=route
?

98035298 over 4 years ago

Hi,
you added crossing way/899282984#map=19/32.17447/34.89213&layers=N
but on Mapillary images from Nov 2020 there is no chance for any pedestrian crossing in this area. Are you 100% sure about it?

107030034 over 4 years ago

Hi, please do not add names for road without explicit street name. Tel Aviv is a destination and not the name.
also, the suffix for hebrew names should be "he" and not "heb".
I'll rollback this changeset.

108437377 over 4 years ago

Hello, FYI, bing images are extremely obsolete, please use them only if you have local knowledge of the area and sure that imagery is still fine.
Specifically here, this roundabout doesn't exists for several months already, so your added crosswalks are not relevant anymore and should be reverted :(

105955654 over 4 years ago

Hi, looks like you used extremely obsolete bing images without local knowledge. This roundabout doesn't exists for like half year already and I removed it some time ago. Now I'll need to fully revert your hard work. Please don't blindly use bing images next time and better check history of ways you going to replace.