Casper, if the DWG concludes that tags should be removed then the DWG will remove these tags. If DWG members privately say that they think soemething is useless, that is NOT sufficient reason to delete whatever that is without any community consultation.

Why did you remove the highway=residential from Elms Road in Sutton Coldfield here, making it vanish from the map?

Clarified in osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Coastline&type=revision&diff=2461993&oldid=2426103

It appears that the node you deleted here used to be a sauna before it was broken by a newbie and then deleted by you. Do you have any information about the true situation on the ground, or did you simply delete something you did not understand?

Please do not create giant relations like this. We do not map continents in OSM; we have specifically invented coastline ways to avoid having to create multipolygons that are so large that nobody can edit them any more.

Dear Hugoren Martinako, you are performing an automated edit on the OpenStreetMap database in Spain. Such edits have to be discussed with the community beforehand. Did you engage in such a discussion and if yes, where can I read about it?

Ich frag mal nach, danke für die Antwort, ich dachte dass Du evtl. irgendwelche Schilder gesehen haben könntest, aber wäre selbst bei Vor-Ort-Mapping nach 9 Jahren vermutlich etwas viel verlangt ;)

Hallo Theodin, vor 9 Jahren hast Du diesen Way way/211717761 bei OSM eingetragen. Ist das - besonders der Teil nordwestlich des Bachs - tatsächlich ein öffentlicher Weg? Die Nutzer der Gebäude am Nordwestende des Wegs haben sich beschwert, dass bei ihnen dauernd Fahrräder durch den Bauernhof fahren ;)

Hallo JJAF, aus welcher Quelle stammten diese Namen, die Du vor 11 Jahren eingetragen hast? Bei der DWG gibt es eine Beschwerde über einen der Namen und ich will gern eine fundierte Antwort schicken.

Hallo Hedaja, ein Mitglied einer Höhlenforschergruppe hat uns geschrieben, dass die Höhle, die Du hier als "Carolahöhle" eingetragen hast, in Wahrheit "Dianahöhle" heisse und auch im sächsischen Höhlenkataster so eingetragen sei. Ich wollte das aber nicht einfach so ändern, ohne Dich vorher zu fragen...

No, but I have emailed UKChris with details.

This trail crosses a footpath without connecting properly. Also, the end of the trail is just metres away from "Easy Line" but does not connect to it. The trail you have drawn here is not visible on aerial imagery - the sharp bend to the South-West is particularly questionable. Please do not upload your GPX files as paths without proper quality control!

I am not sure what you mean by "probably automatically generated". If this is a process that automatically uploads data to OSM without supervision then it needs to follow our data import guidelines osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

What does "None-70" mean?

Dear yopaseopor, you're making a lot of changes spanning all of Spain or even larger areas where your changeset comment is "#fastag" and your "source" is usually given as "OSM data and wiki" or so.

If these are automated edits - where you use some rule to specify "all objects having these tags should (also) have these other tags", then this is an automated edit that needs to be discussed with the community before you execute it. You are expected to document these edits on the wiki. If you're not discussing these edits and not documenting them, and if they are automatic, then please stop them immediately.

In order for it to be *not* an automated edit, you have to review each changed object individually and make a decision. You would, for example, be expected to explain why in this changeset an industrial building that is not a supermarket (way/901524671) has been tagged with a supermarket brand?

Thank you.

Dear Palubalis, in this old changeset you added the path way/673200804 - the DWG now has a complaint from a construction company in the area saying this was a private path and not accessible for hikers. Can you comment on this? (DWG ticket 2022101810000156)

I have re-set way/772773463 to landuse=military. It is apparently an Indian installation but vishal22 has made an attempt to hide that information. Maybe we need an operator tag for that?

Please explain why you have downgraded the Indian army base from a "military" to an "industrial" installation. Is there no military presence here?

Benutzersperre mit Bitte um künftiges Wohlverhalten hier: osm.org/user_blocks/6418 - siehe aber auch changeset/126937564