Ok, but now what is the difference with this node (actual car entrance) node/4278583112

and this node (some intermediate stop) node/4592378548

Hm, seems like I realized why there was a dedicated route=shuttle_train way.

Because it has only start/end points connected with entrance/exit highway ways. Now railway=rail way has a lot of common nodes with other highways and routing engines (without any specific processing) interpret these nodes as possible enter/exit, which is not correct.

Organic Maps

And of course, we as the OSM community should avoid dummy duplicating ways like in La Manche, where existing relation is more than enough. Probably should unify additional tags like shuttle=yes or service=shuttle/car_shuttle or whatever ...

I have already updated our routing engine. And I agree with you that route=train + shuttle=yes is the better scheme here. The same as route=ferry.

Ok, no problem, your arguments are valid here.

Don't know if it is a valid argument here or not, but the famous La Manche shuttle is mapped like route=shuttle_train.

So now routing engines should support both versions COUNT(shuttle_train) == 26, COUNT(shuttle=yes) == 6 ..

Don't put natural=coastline tags. Read the OSM wiki about coastlines first.

- кольцо называется "гостиница Россия"?
- place=locality тут лишнее, кмк

Вы добавляете дубликаты. У maps.me старые данные. Рекомендую Organic Maps.

Seems like coastlines are broken after this changeset. Please, use JOSM editor and make coastlines validation.

Please, check coastlines with validator here. Looks like they are broken now after your edits.

Please, do not set object's name tag like "main road", "secondary road", "building". Primary tags highway=primary, highway=secondary is enough here.

What is the meaning of name="turning point"? Use highway=turning_circle instead.

Please, refer to some docs on how to map objects in OSM, like Getting Started.

Thanks for your contribution here, but please: Do not set object's name tag like "unclassified road", "bank", "river". Primary tag highway=unclassified, amenity=bank is enough here.

Please, refer to some docs on how to map objects in OSM, like Getting Started.

approve this proposal. (vng_me) --Vng me (talk) 04:55, 16 September 2022 (UTC)

{{vote|yes}} (vng_me) --~~~~

This coastline way/878746566 is broken or waste.

Coastlines are broken after this changeset. You should be careful when editing linear/area objects with ID. Better to use JOSM and validator.

This coastline way/962538356 is broken

After adding new coastline geometry here, validator fails. Should remove old coastlines like this way/847219206