trigpoint's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 57155722 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, welcome to OSM.
|
| 57154145 | almost 8 years ago | Why do you say 'not valid'? I can see it on aerial imagery. |
| 57152211 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM we map what exists on the ground. Waitrose warehouse and My Local are not parks. This is vandalism and is being reverted. |
| 57029045 | almost 8 years ago | I have seen the cycleway, the signs were a bit hidden when I was driving.
Permissive means that a landowner has given permission for the public to use paths on their land. That is a very inappropriate tag to use on a public highway. |
| 57063766 | almost 8 years ago | Maybe they can be different, but that is no reason to hold back improvements in mapping technique. |
| 57063766 | almost 8 years ago | Actually I am not actually sure why a light rail would be mapped differently to any other station. |
| 57063766 | almost 8 years ago | I have never heard of OpenAndroMaps, but they should update to reflect improved mapping. We should not tag for the renderer which changing these stations appears to be doing. |
| 57063766 | almost 8 years ago | The wiki is intended to document how mappers map, it is not a set of instructions and should be taken with a large pinch of salt. Mapping evolves over time and I suspect this page has not been updated yet. Whilst an underground station would be difficult to map as an area and a node is appropriate an above ground station can easily be defined as an area and provides a better map. |
| 57063766 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, I am not sure I understand why you have changed this? The wiki says stations can be mapped as areas or nodes. |
| 57029045 | almost 8 years ago | But we map what we see on the ground, we do not have permission to map traffic orders. Which brings me to way/568192362
What is the source of these edits? |
| 57029045 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, way/568194283 is a shared use cycleway/footway. Why would foot access be permissive? |
| 55865573 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, there is no need to tag foot=yes or bicycle=yes on trunk roads. It is assumed to be allowed unless signed otherwise. It is also not just allowed, they are right of way so the correct tagging would be *=designated.
|
| 56907118 | almost 8 years ago | You have also removed the building and place of worship tags. I have reverted this |
| 56907118 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, welcome to OSM. I am a little confused by this change as this has always been Church of England, yet you have changed the denomination to Catholic. I believe that this edit should be undone. Cheers Phil |
| 56632280 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, I am not sure that this will fix the issue with navmii. Oneway is unnecessary on a roundabout Looking back at the history of this, the problem you are seeing was fixed a year ago and based on my experience of navmii the map data has not been updated. I did express my concern to them at SOTM Brussels. They lack resources to provide timely updates. You may want to try an alternative navigation app which uses OSM such as OSMand or maps.me. |
| 56600277 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, thank you for your reply. I do believe that this change should be undone. It does need discussion, I and other mappers do consider these to be different
On the discussion page osm.wiki/Talk:Tag:shop%3Dgift a very good comment has been added "For me, a souvenir shop is where you stop by far away from home to take something along for you, a gift shop is where you get in on the way to the birthday party you forgot about. They are two quite distinct concepts." It also says on the wiki page "Automated edits are strongly discouraged unless you really know what you are doing!" The wiki is supposed to document how mappers, map it should not be taken as an instruction on how to map or what is right or wrong. Cheers Phil |
| 56600277 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, this appears to be an undiscussed mechanical edit. Did you follow the procedure detailed in osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct and if so where was it discussed? In my experience the two are different and this type of tag homogenising just makes for a bland map. |
| 56320592 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, this name does not fit the OSM naming convention. The name should be one or the other. Use either alt_name or loc_name tags for other names.
|
| 56292195 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, this does not fit the wiki description of a living street. It is, as previously tagged a residential street (what it looks like) that has bollards. It is legally a cycleway.
|
| 56280899 | almost 8 years ago | Hi, something has gone a little wrong here, I doubt that the name of the bus stop has been changed and unless something has been demolished please simply change the tag to disused:amenity=fuel. A close garage is still a landmark.
|