Bore da
Just wondering why you have changed the name of Ynys Dewi away from the local language name?

Diolch Phil

Hi, just wondering what sources you are using for these edits. Surveys to find and only map fire hydrants seems a lot of work.
Cheers Phil

I think it is more of a foodie pub than a restaurant, however dogs=unleashed seems strange where food is served.

Got it, in GBG

What does the camra tag mean?

Cheers Phil

Also the concept of StreetComplete is that you mke edits that you can see in front of you. How were you able to make changes in both the US and Germany?

The quest is very badly designed, it seems obsessed with there being a sign and allows an answer "there is no sign" when in reality there is always a sign which will be at the edge of the zone. In this case it could be a couple of miles away.

I never said I reverted the change.

I suspect that all edits by this group of mappers need to be reverted as they have made so many errors. I feel it is unlikely that the US community will have missed things like toll tags.

I spotted this blunder today when OSMand informed me that the speed limit on Western Approach is 70 mph, a bit odd for a city centre road

Not sure why but you tagged is as maxspeed:type=GB:nsl_dual which is clearly very wrong.

Please sanity check your edits.

Cheers Phil

Thank you, however their profile is still not compliant with organised editing guidelines.

You are still not compliant with the organised editing guidelines. Please fix your profile.

Cheers Phil

Hi
What is the source you are using for these edits. An urban primary road isn't going to have a toll so I am unsure how this improves routing.

Cheers Phil

Hi
The wikipedia and wikidata tags you added refer to the hospital object, not a single building.

The wikidata tag already existed on the hospital object and I have added the wikipedia tag there.

Cheers Phil

Hi again
Postcodes are not required on individual buildings as they are on the outer hospital object.

Are you mapping from the US?

Cheers Phil

Thank you, I have removed the duplicate hospital tags and added the correct tags where they exist such as here.

I have not removed any nodes but have left some with just a name. We do not have a scheme for mapping the internals of a hospital in OSM beyond things lke mapping Shropdoc as a doctors and outpatients as a clinic. Stores and porters loading bays are beyond the scope of OSM.

OSM does not have approval, the database is updated immediately but we do rely on local mappers providing peer review.

You are welcome to join the UK community at https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Cheers Phil

Hi, welcome to osm however your edits have gone a little bit wrong.
In OSM we follow the rule "One feature, one OSM element", see osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element

Your edits have broken that, Captain Tom's Garden is a garden, not a hospital, there is only one hospital here, the RSH, that is mapped on the outer way.

OSM is a geographic database and if someone were to perform a query 'how many hospitals in Shropshire they would get a very wrong answer.

Are you mapping as part of your job?

Cheers Phil

Hi Nathaniel
Probably not removed but the tagging should be correct.

I am not sure of the tagging however you will get advice from the mailing list.

Cheers Phil

Hello, welcome to OSM and thank you for your edits however I am concerned that the tagging of these paths may cause problems for some map users.

The name Craig Pennant Scramble implies that a walker may need to use their hands, which is not the general understanding of a path.

The wiki page at highway=path?uselang=en suggests additional tags you can add, such as sac_scale to make the nature of the route clearer.

OSM has had concerns raised in the path where walkers following their smartphone app get into difficulties because it is not the walk along a clearly defined path they were expecting.

You may want to discuss this type of edit with the UK community who are very knowledgable, https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Cheers Phil

Thank you however you shouldn't be looking at Google maps when mapping in OSM, it is against their terms of use.

We do not normally map short term closures such as this because many data consumers only take OSM data very rarely and the closure can persist on maps long after it has been reopened. It is also likely to be missed in OSM and be spotted years later.

Cheers Phil

Exactly, from looking at the sabre wiki which says that the A6 was routed this way in 2014, not that the road opened in 2014.

These edits need to be reverted.