OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
52709499 about 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. Please do not mistag things, this is described as a clinic so it should not be mapped as a hospital as that is extremely misleading for other map users.
Please use amenity=clinic, you may need to use a proper OSM editor such as iD to change this.

52627613 about 8 years ago

Thank you for your reply.

Places with childrens playgrounds and grassy areas for sport are recreation grounds and are far more common. Parks are for more formal places such as Abbey Park for example.

Cheers Phil

52627613 about 8 years ago

Hi, this was originally mapped as a recreation ground. OS Opendata call it a recreation ground, I would call it a recreation ground. Why did you change it and what is the source of the name?
Cheers Phil

52593474 about 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your conribution however it has gone a little wrong. When adding things do please look at the map and ensure that they do not already exist. We also have a rule of one real life object=one osm object.

Swansea West Fire Station was already mapped as a relation. You have duplicated this information by adding the same information to the building.

Swansea Central Fire Station was also already mapped as a relation, you have created a duplicate by adding the same information to the building.

Morriston Fire Station was also already mapped, but lacked detail. You have created a duplication by adding the same information to the land area and the building.

It is all an easy mistake to make, especially when begining to map in an area that is already mapped, are you able to fix these or would you like some help?

Cheers Phil

51758719 about 8 years ago

I have removed the wikidata tags from the statue of Charles Darwin and the bust of Mary Webb.
I had linked to wikipedia sections on commemerations, not to articles about the person. The wikdata refers to the person, which is not correct in this case.
Cheers Phil

48951250 about 8 years ago

Thank you

48951250 about 8 years ago

Hi, what on the ground evidence do you have that Watling Street is in modern usage on for example way/5061100 ? have you been there and seen a sign?

Adding names that do not exist on the ground is very misleading to map users, would the residents of Frodesley who live along this road give their address as Watling Street?

Cheers Phil

52428611 about 8 years ago

Hi, what is the source of Telford Estate, those who live there say they live in Monkmoor.

52420815 over 8 years ago

Hi, the names you are adding appear to be transliterations which should not be added to OSM. See osm.wiki/Names#Avoid_transliteration

Last time I was in Telford or Wellington there were certainly no Russian Names on the signs.

This edit should be reverted.

52305211 over 8 years ago

Hi, this edit looks a bit odd. Costa is not normally an internet cafe, in fact I have never heard of them providing computers. I would also expect it to be in a building rather than the road.

52280417 over 8 years ago

Hi, has the car park been built on?
If so then it would be better to delete it as the area was already residential and you now have a residential polygon with another residential polygon.
Cheers Phil

52276836 over 8 years ago

Hi, I assume this should be Bill's Bar rather than Bill's Bar Bar?

Cheers Phil

52238824 over 8 years ago

Hi, the correct way to tag a closed pub is to change the amenity tag to disused:amenity=pub. I would leave the name in place if it is still visible.
Cheers Phil

52196925 over 8 years ago

Power league is a very odd surface, I assume it should be in name?

52128706 over 8 years ago

Hi
In OSM we have a rule of one feature, one object in OSM. See osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element
There is only one hospital, so different departments should not have an amenity-hospital tag.
Please remember that OSM is a geographic database, so please do not map to make it look neater in one of many renderers.
Thanks Phil

52181464 over 8 years ago

Thank you for fixing the spelling.

I am removing the address information, I am not certain that the address is correct as it moved and that number doesn't seem right, and a bit pointless as retail places rarely display a number.
The website you quoted clearly says that it is copyright so you should not have copied the postcode.
I would prefer to leave the shop as candy, as that expresses what it is. It is where I go to get my candy
At the time I mapped it, there were lot of shop=candy, but I guess they have been armchaired away making the database clean but loosing real world expression.
Cheers Phil

52181464 over 8 years ago

Also what is the source you used to find the postcode?

52181464 over 8 years ago

Hi, please could you explain why you made this change?
OSM has a system of free tagging which allows mappers to express what they see, and survey regularly, on the ground. The aim is not database purity.
The word candy was chosen to express what is sold there.
Cheers Phil

52116614 over 8 years ago

Hi, the website should refer to the object you are mapping and should not be the company's website.
Cheers Phil

52072233 over 8 years ago

Fiction reverted