OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
48337343 over 8 years ago

I received a reply to this as a private message, for changeset discussions it is better to keep these discussion public where they can be seen by all mappers.

The whole is known as Swarkestone Bridge by most people, but most don't consider the detail in the way that a mapper does. The actual bridge is the section that crosses The Trent.
The section that was previously tagged as Swarkestone Causeway is its name (the name tag is not for adding detail or descriptions). There is a large brown sign at the southern end with that name on it.
A bit out of focus but I have been that way many many times https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=52.843430900000016&lng=-1.4485190999999986&z=17&pKey=pq4fRH6dOQhWDZ0jz6ujow&focus=photo&x=0.5604635003420566&y=0.5296476193112039&zoom=1.2231030577576445

As Mike says there are bridges within the structure, but these are very short and maybe a case for added detail but it the whole section is certainly not a bridge, as you can seen when you walk the rights of way beside it. It is mostly solid.
Cheers Phil

48337343 over 8 years ago

Hi, what is your reason and source for this change? Have you been there?
The section you have tagged as a bridge is very definitely a causeway, and it is called simply Swarkestone Causeway.
I will see what other local mappers view is, but mine is that this should be reverted.
Cheers Phil

48031445 over 8 years ago

The biergarten tag is a little out of place. I suspect it is a pub beer garden.
amenity=biergarten?uselang=en

48248316 over 8 years ago

I am reverting these edits, they are very definitely recreation grounds

48234563 over 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. The Guards Museum is already mapped. I am removing this duplication

48228126 over 8 years ago

I have put the buildings back, less pub and health centre tags

48228126 over 8 years ago

Thank you for your relply, I will revert this change to put the buildings back and then correct the tagging.

48228233 over 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. Is this a verifable office with signs I would see if I walked down Adelphi Road?

48228126 over 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM.
I am always a bit concerned when a new mappers first edit is to just delete things.
You have not explained what was wrong with the Health Centre but the building seems to match what is on bing imagery so maybe the tags should be changed but deleting the building is not the way to change things. Also you say that the pub has closed, if so remove the pub tags but has the building been demolished?
I would suggest this change be reverted and changes made correctly.

48057569 over 8 years ago

Hi, SOFA should be mapped as shop=charity, charity=furniture. You will need to use a proper editor such as iD to change it though. Give me a shout if you need a hand.

48079366 over 8 years ago

Stirling Castle is already mapped in great detail, a node doesn't add anything so I am reverting this edit.

48084079 over 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. I am not sure a community centre is really the way to describe a yacht club. Plus it is already mapped as.a marina.

48018758 over 8 years ago

Hi, thank you for adding the car park however you have made a common beginners mistake by putting a description in the name field. If the car park doesn't have a name, then leave the name field blank.
Cheers Phil

47981886 over 8 years ago

There are more changes here than your stated incorrect layer.
You have also changed oneway=-1 to oneway=yes on way/204098940 thus reversing the direction of travel for that section

47947482 over 8 years ago

Hi, please can you point me to where this mechanical edit was discussed?
You seem to have mechanically armchaired layer=1 onto bridges with no survey, if you had you would have seen that the bridge should be at layer=0 and maybe whatever is below them needs a later=-1 where it is below ground level.
Many are plank footbridges that are mapped for PROW completeness and are certainly not above ground.
Each of these cases needs an actual survey, it cannot be determined from an armchair.
For example https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=52.851990150000006&lng=-2.72679801000001&z=17&pKey=nEq-hE5PAqA4be5EM62PkQ&focus=photo is certainly at 'ground' level.
Also some were just mistagged in the first place, such as way/91002981/history. Rather than fix the problem you have just added an extra tag.

47844875 over 8 years ago

Its a recreation ground, reverted

47844669 over 8 years ago

Reverted, not a park

47844839 over 8 years ago

It is in a park, but this is a football pitch. Reverted

47950853 over 8 years ago

Hi, please could you add some more detail to the artworks. A pub car park is an odd place for an artwork.
Thanks Phil

47965805 over 8 years ago

Hi, way/188281048 does not need to be mapped as a tunnel. The road is already mapped as a bridge.