OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
118142482 almost 4 years ago

This is... not a good way to inform the russian people that their leader is like Hitler. It is the opposite of a good way. The good way is to start mapping in countries nearby Poland to help refugees.

117628622 almost 4 years ago

Nice to meet you! Saw your work in Centralia - three questions.

1. Why are you making the trees overlap the buildings? OSM is a map of what's on the ground, not what you can see from satellite imagery. I doubt the building suddenly disappears under the cover of a tree.

2. Why are individual trees mapped as areas? They should be mapped as nodes. natural=wood is used for entire forests.

3. Specifically for the washington lawn cemetery, what's up with that? Does the cemetery not exist when there's tree cover? That does not look like the on-the-ground shape.

Thanks,
snoozingnewt

117555302 almost 4 years ago

You’re missing something glaring

117555302 almost 4 years ago

We understand you need to make money, but there are also rules… we’re judging you for not taking the time to look at them even after several people complained. You aren’t entitled to break them.

117555302 almost 4 years ago

First of all-

It’s not just you! We have quite a few experiences with people from the metaverse vandalizing the map, so the general sentiment is against the metaverse. OSM is primarily used as a map of the real world and had existed for decades, and it is not in existence primarily to add gaming data. You can still add it, but it needs to follow the rules the rest of the world does.

Adding many nodes doesn’t increase quality significantly. However, it adds a lot of data to the map. The servers can handle it, but there are several reasons why it is still bad-

1. If you shape of the lake is updated in the future, it would be a huge pain to change it.

2. There’s no real-world reason to do so, at least until now. Maybe the game likes the level of detail, but the community doesn’t, and OSM is almost entirely built off of community consensus.

3. Some people use an editor (like iD) to edit the map, and they download an area to edit. Places with a ton of detail make it harder for those people to edit, because they have to load ridiculously small areas near complicated places, like this golf course.

117555302 almost 4 years ago

OSM has a wiki with general community preferences, and you've violated several of them. When you join a community, do you not read the rules and jump right in - especially in a site that has real-world consequences. The resolution on the bodies of water and other objects is considered unacceptable for OSM for several reasons - the iD editor should give warnings when you break them.

117268840 almost 4 years ago

Oops - I also added another forest near Webster Springs too

114721557 about 4 years ago

These buildings are not accurate shapes - can you please try to make them more accurate and fix these ones? Thanks!

114499553 about 4 years ago

You're not allowed to delete that.

113945580 about 4 years ago

Hi, can you please explain this tag that you used in this changeset?

common_good=yes

113767994 about 4 years ago

Are you sure all of these buildings are squared? I saw a few that seemed very slightly off

113673561 about 4 years ago

Hi, can you please use more constructive changeset comments? I'm also not sure why you deleted that bus stop, so can you explain that as well? Thanks!

113539825 about 4 years ago

Thanks for mapping! Make sure to square all rectangular buildings you make with the "Q" key. It makes them look much nicer!
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/113539825

113539585 about 4 years ago

Thanks for mapping! Make sure to square each building you make with the "Q" key. By doing so, they are more realistic and look much better!
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/113539585

112428814 about 4 years ago

Honestly, if *two* nodes are being edited it'd be much easier to get this done in two tiny changesets than one slightly bigger changeset that spans the entire world.

110553610 over 4 years ago

Why did you change this road to primary?

110381501 over 4 years ago

Hi, can you please make more descriptive changeset comments?
Thanks!

110029246 over 4 years ago

Is the government office really named "aaaaaaaaa"?

109227189 over 4 years ago

Ok, that's fine.

108430155 over 4 years ago

"What is the colour of this building: way/373879419/history ?
On what grounds have you decided that it is grey, not white?"