OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
43521892 almost 9 years ago

Can I remind you of the lifecycle concept, so one can put 'disused:' in front of the primary key (in this case amenity).
For more detail see: osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix
Alternatively if the phone box has been totally removed, one can just delete the node in OSM.

45014996 almost 9 years ago

Hmm something wrong on JOSM upload, my comment was meant to be: "Junction name, signed incline and fix peak position."

40304344 almost 9 years ago

I also read that it had reopened in WightWash (CAMRA IoW magazine) but I forgot to mention that.

44963942 almost 9 years ago

The Wikidata ID for at least the Amsterdam Shipwreck was valid, so why did you remove it?

40304344 almost 9 years ago

The Sportsmans Rest looks like it's reopened as I went past it the other day.
However for things that are closed you shouldn't really modify the name, but instead put 'disused:' in front of the primary key.
See osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix for more information

44784027 almost 9 years ago

Hmm something wrong on JOSM upload, my comment was meant to be: "Postbox detail and public telephone has become a mini library"

42953117 about 9 years ago

I'm not sure where you get your information from as: 1) The Trafalgar has been closed since the end of summer 2016 and 2) The location is a bit inaccurate as it is nearer Edinburgh Road.

43560059 about 9 years ago

It's probably a good idea to mark this as private as it's not for general public use.

43521907 about 9 years ago

The original one is in the right position and also has more tags

43521907 about 9 years ago

Ummm Sant Yago is already mapped.

42921749 about 9 years ago

If the telephone is now removed - one should use the lifecycle concept to prevent others (and computers) thinking this is still operational.
Basically put 'disused:' in front of the primary tag - in this case the amenity tag so it would become 'disused:amenity'.
For more detail see disused=*:

41967078 over 9 years ago

My comment was meant to be:

Southern Transit road is not for public use

40453931 over 9 years ago

You seemed to have made Worthing Road an angular bend here.
Surely it's more of a smooth curve?

40453931 over 9 years ago

You seemed to have made Worthing Road somewhat of an angular bend here.
Surely it's more of a smooth curve?

40446838 over 9 years ago

foot=yes is *not* needless on a highway=footway, typically it can elude to the path being an official Right of Way.
Often people used this tagging before the community settled on the unambiguous designation=public_footpath tagging.

39674107 over 9 years ago

You may want to get familiar to life cycle concepts to describe no longer 'active' features.
See disused=*:
This this should be tagged-
disused:amenity=postbox
Thus allowing map and data users to more easily understand the availability of features.

39849443 over 9 years ago

Pubs are normally tagged as amenity=pub not shop=bathroom_furnishing!

You possibly didn't mean to move the bus stop either...

39544390 over 9 years ago

'a' is not a useful comment.
Please try to describe your changes (and why you made them) to help other mappers understand your edits.

24262177 over 9 years ago

What is your source for these 'peaks'.
Most seem just to be vaguely near high point of a bit of landscape (as seen by a OS 1-inch 7th Series 1955-61 spot height), which IMHO is not a peak.

37528637 almost 10 years ago

I'm not sure how this 'fixes' tags.
Anything machine reading tag that can handle ';' should be able to handle white space.

Besides it's probably simpler just to tag it as one amenity type (i.e. a restaurant - as it's even in their web address - http://www.poppinsrestaurants.co.uk/)