ralley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 100528792 | almost 5 years ago | Despite multiple discussions on your changesets requesting otherwise you are still making huge changesets and not using meaningful comments. Please break your changsets up into smaller geographical areas and use meaningful comments as per: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments#:~:text=A%20good%20changeset%20comment%20should,have%20edited%20on%20the%20map. Please reply to this discussion so we can tell you are reading these.
|
| 100376809 | almost 5 years ago | Re: Z Wairou you have removed the building tag from the building and replaced it with amenity tags when there is already a node with more detailed amenity tags
|
| 100377722 | almost 5 years ago | Please dont tag descriptions like "R.O.W." in the name key: osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
|
| 100377156 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to SOM and thanks for your edit. I've drawn in the area of the childcare centre and added the amenity=kindergarten tag.
|
| 100203391 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. Just a pointer that might make your life easier: in NZ the majority of buildings consist of mostly 90 degree corners. You can easily make all corners 90 degrees in the Id editor by selecting the building, right clicking and choosing “Square”.
|
| 100077490 | almost 5 years ago | Also please don't put personal information like "John Home" in the name field: osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
|
| 100077490 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. Why have you tagged the schoold building with layer=-1? That would indicate it is underground.
|
| 99273006 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edit, looks good to me. The only thing I noticed was that you added the address when there is already a node with that address. It's not a major problem but you could have merged the existing node with your building outline or just left the node inside the outline and not added address info to the outline.
|
| 99224106 | almost 5 years ago | Please don't use the name field for descriptions like "shopping precinct", it is for proper names: osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don.27t_use_name_tag_to_describe_things
|
| 98594304 | almost 5 years ago | Glacier Burn Track is alrady mapped as way way/755484272
|
| 98479028 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. The normal practice in New Zealand is not to add sidewalks as seperate ways but instead use the "refinement of highway" approach where sidewalk tags are added to the parent road instead. See sidewalk=* Using that method it is generally much easier to maintain topological correctness for routing.
|
| 98464314 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. When adding phone numbers please use ITU-T E.164 format as per phone=*
|
| 98264555 | almost 5 years ago | Please don't edit the underlying map in an attempt to create personalised routes. There are applications which use OSM as a base map with which you can create routes instead.
|
| 97924961 | almost 5 years ago | Why have you put layer=-1 on way/898090359 ? It is visible in aerial imagery so is not underground.
|
| 97923397 | almost 5 years ago | Also Mokoroa Falls Track is still closed according to DOC (https://www.doc.govt.nz/parks-and-recreation/places-to-go/auckland/places/muriwai-and-te-henga-area/tracks/mokoroa-falls-track/), and Goldie Bush Walkway (https://www.doc.govt.nz/parks-and-recreation/places-to-go/auckland/places/muriwai-and-te-henga-area/tracks/goldie-bush-walkway/) are closed but will now appear as open on the map
|
| 97923397 | almost 5 years ago | Mokoroa Stream Track is closed according to DOC (see https://www.doc.govt.nz/parks-and-recreation/places-to-go/auckland/places/muriwai-and-te-henga-area/tracks/mokoroa-stream-track/) but you have added back foot=yes which marks it as open. Is it truely re-opened?
|
| 97801227 | almost 5 years ago | Eliot has cleared this up in the comments on changeset/6750217 |
| 97726494 | almost 5 years ago | Why have you removed the building tags from these?
|
| 97691052 | almost 5 years ago | Sorry I just realised tagging the ditch (way/459979616) with name="Water Race" was done in a previous changeset by another user.
|
| 97691052 | almost 5 years ago | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits, please don't add generic descriptions to the name field: osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
|