OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
71643868 over 6 years ago

I just pulled up the tags the validator did on the Civic Center Station, and it looks like it made them amenity=bus_station. Are you saying it should be using a building=* tag instead? Even without a validator, I'd consider the former tag to be a building if put as an area. What do you think?

51125374 almost 7 years ago

When you're adding opening_hours values, please make sure you're using the standard format as described in the wiki opening_hours=*

Specifically, you're leaving out the colons, and you're using commas for separators when semicolons are standard OSM for multiple values in a field. As an example:

Mo 10:00-12:00,12:30-15:00; Tu-Fr 08:00-12:00,12:30-15:00; Sa 08:00-12:00

These issues came up in a JOSM validation search. I'm fixing them manually.

66912599 almost 7 years ago

And the other aspect is, I talked to Denver GIS about this problem and asked what the official name is. They said the city of Denver is officially recognizing all streets like this to officially include the directional indicator as part of the name, but the DPW can take their sweet time in changing the signs over. I'm moving into this neighborhood, and I know my address includes East on it on our official paperwork. I am familiar with the on the ground rule. Is the answer to use "Cherry Creek South" with altname to "East" until the signs get updated, or is there a precedent for changing the data to match addresses being assigned to the neighborhood?

66912599 almost 7 years ago

https://www.denvergov.org/media/gis/WebDocs/Assessment/AssessorMaps/asmt_06184.pdf

66912599 almost 7 years ago

Take a look at this assessors map of a portion of the roadway, showing the East is reflected officially in the name of the road.

66912599 almost 7 years ago

Thanks for your comment. Source for the change came from address, parcel, and assessor maps from Denver GIS which show the street to be named this way. Is that authoritative? What would you recommend we do? If reversion of the data is necessary, because there's other things in here than just the street, I'd prefer to create a different change set and change it all back manually if I had to.

63629738 about 7 years ago

That is a very strange circumstance. What I might do in this case is extend the roadway into Dedham, and give the portion in Dedham the name "Place", so at least your house is connected to a roadway that is searchable on the map. I'll do that for you. :)

63079408 about 7 years ago

Good edit, thanks for contributing to OSM! :)

63520206 about 7 years ago

Wow, great work! Thanks for providing such detailed information for OpenStreetMap! Keep on mapping!

63629738 about 7 years ago

Welcome, and thanks for joining and editing OSM!

Your most recent edit looks great, but I did notice the street name you put on the building is "Goethe Place" instead of "Goethe Street". Can you confirm which one is accurate? If the street name is wrong, we can edit that!

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

63642628 about 7 years ago

Wow, great work on your recent edits! Thanks for providing such detailed information for OSM! Keep on mapping!

63429709 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to take a look at it.

There's a couple issues with your edit. First, you seem to have added this information as a place of worship, and not a florist/flower shop, and so the main type of business is not correct.

Secondly, you placed the pointer for the business in the middle of a roadway, and not on top of 127 Poplar Street. In OSM, we follow an "On The Ground" rule - entries into OSM must exist verifiably in the real world. When placing business points, you must put the where the business is located, and you can't place them in the middle of the street.

I have corrected both problems for you. Please take note of the editing guidelines and new editor guides at osm.wiki/Contribute_map_data and osm.wiki/How_We_Map

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

61149289 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to comment on your edit.

I'm looking at Talbot and Bernard. Is your question how to map an intersection with multiple entrances and traffic lights separated like that? This intersection actually appears to be mapped very well! The only thing I'd check is you might have a no left turn restriction from Bernard going north onto Talbot. If that's the case, you can click on the traffic light and on the left side see a turn restriction editor. Highlight each way traffic would be coming from to add rules for that intersection.

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

63489315 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to comment on your edit.

Excellent work with your first edit! All of the tags and features you added for your home look perfect.

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

63493053 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to comment on your edit.

I am happy to report that your test edit did go through successfully, however leaving edits like this is considered cluttering and counterproductive to the community built dataset we have here. I'd recommend to you to test out the features of the editor by adding businesses or other local features that exist in real life, rather than a test message.

It would be appreciated if you could please delete the test node from the map you created. If you're having trouble with this, I will delete it for you in a day.

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

63494738 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to comment on your edit.

Very nice work editing the map with swapping these two nodes. Did you know that nodes can also contain complete business information? If you were so inclined, you could go back and enter in all kinds of things, like phone numbers, addresses, and even what kind of payment they take there.

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

63512906 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to comment on your edit.

Very good job recognizing the library wasn't here, and editing all those tags. You had still left the type=public tag in there, and you might consider going back later and removing that, else members of the general public could be awkwardly confused trying to walk into this persons house. :)

Thanks for your contribution to the map! You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

63658963 about 7 years ago

Welcome to OSM! You had marked you wanted someone to review your edit, and I thought I'd take the time to say you did great! Don't forget, you can also add additional features about the gift shop, like what kinds of payment it takes, its phone number, address, or even its store hours. Just select the node for the shop again, and the iD editor will show all the options available to you on the left side. You can also see more about editing by visiting learnosm.org. Thanks, and happy mapping!

60507755 over 7 years ago

Hi there! Can you tell me, what are you attempting to map here? You tagged this simply an "area", but should probably be something more specific. How can I help you? way/606055432#map=16/42.3556/-71.0606

60472897 over 7 years ago

Donovan, I took a look at your edit per review requested tag. It looks good, but my only suggestion would be to make the ends of the park align with the curbstone ends at the street, and not spread into the street intersection. You want to map according to what it really looks like, don't map to make the renderer look pretty. If you edit the top and bottom sections down to the edge of the curbstones, it gives a better indication of where the greenspace ends and the roadway begins.