Hi yamanq,

This path existed as a detour pedestrian route in 2020 while the Kinesiology Building (formerly Kraus Natural Science Building) was under construction. Is this edit based on aerial imagery from before 2020, or have you visited in 2021 to verify this path's demolition?

-Noah
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111832694

Hello!

Edits in this apartment complex have been good! This pool should probably be leisure=swimming_pool instead of natural=water though. I updated it in changeset/111785718
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111707896

Hi Michael,

Building edits look good. You can use the keyboard shortcut "q" to square the corners of a way, especially useful for buildings.

Bus edits look fine too.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111782910

Revised changeset/111770419

I will change the school now! Thanks for the land use updates in the area. I've been working on land use in SE Oakland County too. If you edit in JOSM let me know because I have some nice imagery from the county from MiSAIL.

Hello Ian,

Changes to the fairways to not overlap the greens look good. The addition of golf=pin to the greens is uncommon because they move every day, but it's not wrong to mark them according to imagery. My only concern is that the row of boxes due west of the clubhouse should all be golf=tee instead of golf=pin because they are tee boxes for the driving range.

-Noah

Hello! I recently edited the schools on the Key Elementary/Oak Park Prep Campus to match the new landuse schema for multiple schools on a single campus. Instead of using amenity=school for the whole schoolground way, a node with amenity=school is placed inside each building and landuse=education is used for the schoolground. It doesn't render yellow yet, but I assume it'll be added in a future Carto update.

Reference link osm.wiki/File:Amenity_school_usage_example_complex_-_Proposal.svg

Updated in changeset/111594665
changeset/111594665

Hi! Thanks for contributing. I'd like to suggest a change to the opening hours format to match the wiki. Here is the page with examples. opening_hours=*. In this case, I've formatted it for you to edit.

Mo 09:00-18:00; Tu 08:00-17:00; Th 14:00-19:00; Fr 08:00-14:00

Second, the description key should not be used for advertising. It is encouraged to add your business to OSM, but the description should be limited to information that can aid other mappers or provide detail to an end user. Here is the wiki for the description key. description=*
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111578100

Hello! Is this a community garden? If yes, it would be better tagged as leisure=garden and garden:type=community instead of landuse=farmland. garden:type=*
-Noah
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111176120

In iD editor, you can use the keyboard shortcut "q" to square the corners of a building or way after once it is closed.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111179434

In iD editor, you can use the keyboard shortcut "q" to square the corners of a building or way after once it is closed.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/111180330

Thanks for the catch!

Clawson is looking good! Nice work.

-Noah

Fantastic, I'll take a look today. Thanks for your work both in OSM and in PGA 2K21!

I see. Yes, the looking at the changesets source for my edits was listed as mapbox, which in the Detroit metro area is the highest resolution but not the most recent imagery (it seems to me Maxar is most recent). Your edits for practice area would be correct then.

For fairway surrounding greens, I believe when I last saw this course there was a fairway trim and a fringe trim around the greens, which led me to map the fairway around the greens. If this is a problem for PGA import, this is such a minor difference that it would be just fine to leave it.

For multipolygons, I'll just revisit this in a few weeks and amend the rough/fairway multipolygons and leave all the tags. Does that work for your PGA import workflow?

Are you using the TGC Designer Tools application from Chad Rockey? It's great that there's a use for OSM for golf course import to the HB Studios golf games, but I had previously mapped the course following the practices prescribed by the golf_course wiki and these changesets stray from those best practices. Particularly they deviate with use of a single way for something that should be a multipolygon, which is not just a golf mapping best practice but a general OSM best practice. Perhaps if are not familiar with multipolygons I can teach you to use them for your future golf course edits?

Have you finished the import of Franklin Hills to PGA 2K21? If yes, can we discuss a revert of the changesets back to the standard mapping practices?

-Noah

Forgot to mention, I can be reached on OSM US slack in the #golf channel

Please check out best practice for fairways around grens on the wiki here. osm.wiki/File:Golf.png

Also, for golf features with cutouts in the centers, multipolygons should be used instead of wrapping a way close to itself. This would be great for fairways and rough.

I can be reached if I can help in any way.

-Noah

Resolved overlapping buildings with jagged edges in changeset/101130680