OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
118405138 almost 4 years ago

fixme: ¿qué hay que cambiar?
office=government - ¿qué gobierno?
leaf_type y leaf_cycle no son útiles con estas etiquetas.
¿Podría utilizar etiquetas que mantengan conexiones lógicas?

118968582 almost 4 years ago

I fixed some of the errors that were created by TaxusB, after my revert. Probably a misunderstanding of the access=* tag.
changeset/119012449
Also see:
changeset/119000265

119000265 almost 4 years ago

Hi TaxusB,
You don't understand the way tags are to be used, as now all of your changes are invalid!
It should be:
highway=path
access=private
And never use a name=* to describe other properties.
I have changed your edits accordingly.
changeset/119012449

Best regards,
Marc Zoutendijk
OpenStreetMap Foundation
Data Working Group

118968582 almost 4 years ago

Hi TaxusB,
I have reverted both of your changesets:
changeset/118993494
changeset/118993388
Please take care when you start to edit the highways by adding the appropriate access tags.
Do not delete anything.

Marc.

118893027 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5848

118932433 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5848

118615607 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5848

118968582 almost 4 years ago

Hi TaxusB,
Thank you for your information.
The best plan is this:
I revert all the deletions you did, whereafter you can add the proper access rights to those paths.
Trails on private land can best be tagged with access=private. Don't delete anything.
Best regards,
Marc.

118968582 almost 4 years ago

Hello TaxusB,
OSM uses the "on the ground" principle. This means that objects, roads, paths, rivers and so on, which are visible in the landscape, are indeed drawn on the map.
Those rules are described here:
osm.wiki/Ground_truth
But the fact that a road is on the map does not mean that it is accessible to everyone!
OSM uses the so called access rights, and with that we can clearly indicate that a road is only accessible for e.g. the owner, or for fire and police.
The roads you removed were marked as highway=path, without any restrictions. But by adding access=permit or access=forestry, the access for those paths can be restricted.
Other mapmakers who use OSM as a bais will then know not to include those paths in their route proposals.
Here you can see the different options that are used for access rights:
access=*#List_of_possible_values

Especially for emergencies (think ambulances or fire department) it is important that all roads and paths are on the map. OSM is very widely used by such organizations and often base their private maps on OSM.

I recommend that you undo the deletions you have made and provide the paths with the appropriate access rights. If you do not know how to do such a "revert", the DWG can do it for you.

Best regards,
Marc Zoutendijk
OpenStreetMap Foundation
Data Working Group

118438340 almost 4 years ago

DWG is now in the process of reverting this building import.
To follow progress see:
@marczoutendijk_repair/history.
This might take at least one more day.

118902834 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5845

Marc Zoutendijk
OpenStreetMap Foundation
Data Working Group

118866175 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5825

Marc Zoutendijk
OpenStreetMap Foundation
Data Working Group

118848407 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5822

118848467 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5822

118869666 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5822

118799125 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5819

118832076 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5819

118832472 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5819

118438340 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5816

Marc Zoutendijk
OpenStreetMap Foundation
Data Working Group

118749354 almost 4 years ago

osm.org/user_blocks/5815