using multipolygon to map a patch of sandbar?

in a way I am quite relieved that most local mappers are not really into micro mapping, and keeping the kiss principle close to their hearts.

Assalamualaikum. selamat datang ke osm.
i) building level = 1 tak perlu kerana ni adalah nilai default (bahasa baku = nilai lalai).
2) house ni kita guna utk rumah sebijik2 mcm bungalow atau kat kampung tu. guna building=terrace (yg ni digunapakai meluas) utk rumah teres.
iii) rumah teres kalau ada jalan potong kat tengah2 tu kena diasingkan mengikut blok, jgn jadikan sebagai satu blok.

jumpa lagi!
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/147199355

assalamualaikum. selamat dtg ke OSM warigh! per review request:

1) landuse=park ni kengkadang lebih sesuai kepada kawasan yang lebih luas mcm taman kat tongah somban nun. cuba tengok kalau tag recreation area lebih tepat utk padang permainan taman.

2) bab nama. Kalau memang ada terpampang papan tanda tulis nama "Taman Permainan bla bla bla", kita boleh taruk name=*. Tapi kalau setakat nama yg diguna oleh orang taman aja tanpa nama rasmi, gunakan loc_name=*.

3) bab address ni jarang yg dijumpa dan diguna pakai untuk taman. bab ni selalunya nominatim (server kat OSM) akan rumus sendiri kat mana taman ni berada. Kalau addr:street, mesti nama jalan tu wujud dekat2 situ, takleh taruk nama tempat.

what happened here?

bos, flower shop ka atau mini nursery?
kalau kedai bunga, tambah shop=florist,
kalau mini nursery boleh tambah shop=garden_centre. shop=garden_centre

Hi, welcome to OSM. Selamat datang eh... :)

per your review request:
- we local mappers used to use living street before this, but most of us decided to stop using it since in actuality that classification requires an official declaration that the street is such. (some of us still use it on dead end 'lorong' in taman perumahan though, it is an understanding that anybody driving fast enough to hit a kid on those street will be dealt harshly by the residents. hehe)

- usually streets around flats are designated as service roads, however my personal contention is that if there''s a street name for it then it's either residential (in flats area) or unclassified.

- most lower classed roads have the implicit allowance for bicycle, foot and everything else (except horses) - default values. No need to include them in the tags. However put restrictions if there's any.

- you can use straighten lines (S on iD) to make the roads straight. First you chop them into segments, then straighten, then finally combine them again.

- you can add a point and designate the place as neighborhood and name it. For apartments/flat areas, it is preferable to create a polygon around the areas, then tag it landuse=residential, and name it. Further, you can refine with barrier = fence, barrier lift gate, access rights etc etc as appropriate.

Sorry for the lengthy comments. shoulda emailed you I guess. Bye!

Pada aku masih lagi kategori description - bezanya dia letak papan tanda. Tgh edit mega nih..

Where did you get the name of the residential streets in this place? way/1225857609 and the adjacent one?

Yang Lorong 5 ni kira driveway ka? banyak rumah lain sepanjang jalan ni, sedangkan kalau driveway (American) defaultnya laluan ke satu rumah sahaja. (sebab tu ada news pasal org kena tembak sbb tersalah masuk driveway, kalau driveway milik org ramai ownernya yg mental takkan defensif camtu)

Right. If I could reference to google, I woulda completed mapping my whole country quite a while ago.

You ever read the discussion on local tagging practice regarding service roads?

Where do you get the street names from?

why are changing the highways to service?

Ha... something is messed up somewhere I guess. I was on JOSM with kartaview layer turned on, but there's no recording shown in this area. Oh well, Grab/kartaview is not known to be that good at maintaining their side of services.

Where do you get the names for these roads?

Pekan Salak Selatan as landuse retail? Not entirely correct I would assume since Pekan is more in the town/suburb category.

Don't entirely agree. Redundancy is something that OSM seems to be fundamentally against.

Why do you add name:ms for items in Malaysia? You do realize this :
'The default name (occupying the 'name' tag without suffix) should be the name in whatever language is used locally. Here is an example of the usage.' -from osm wiki

Lebih kemas ke, atau nak ikut google? ;)
Pernah jumpa berkilometer jalan double line yang terpisah camtu, nak kata kemas pun idak juga. Penin ada la. Yang selalu nak separate ni adalah disebabkan nak mudah buat bus route tapi ada JOSM senang aja.

Pernah terfikir jugak nak buat, tapi bercanggah dengan prinsip physical separation yang sebenarnya ada juga kepentingannya. So, turn restriction pun turn restriction la, nak buat camna. Inipun kacang je nak buat dalam JOSM.

Rasanya satu tempat je yang sesuai nak buat separation camtu iaitu susur keluar/masuk yang ada area triangle cat belang2, sebabnya ialah selalunya tak berkait sangat dengan jalan2 lain. (dalam hati terdetik juga nak delete heh)

Kenapa Jalan Bukit Kemuning terpisah kepada dua? Dahulu dah dipisah, kemudian dibetulkan kepada 2-way street, lepas tu dipisahkan balik?

Kita nak pisahkan jalan double line ke?