OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
163869963 8 months ago

Carto wasn't rendering it before. It is now-I think what might have happened is when you split the way, the inner role for the relation was only transferred to one of the resulting ways. JOSM showed me a "unclosed MP" error. You're right, I should have let you know before fixing it. Sorry about that.

163869963 8 months ago

Hello! Looks to me like relation/18868946 broke here. I've fixed it.

165049659 8 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

164920557 8 months ago

Reverted

changeset/164959980

164485137 9 months ago

Looks good. Welcome to OSM!

164444274 9 months ago

Welcome back to OSM!

164101185 9 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

163932247 9 months ago

Reverted

changeset/163969778

163304341 10 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

162938397 10 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

162803161 10 months ago

Hello,
Please take another look at the data you've imported as well as the various wiki pages for the Canvec import. I see some issues right away:
1. You appear to be importing more than the approved data types (e.g. relation/18736785 , way/1361881766 , way/1361881990)
2. Footways overlapping other highways. No highway=* objects from Canvec should be uploaded. (e.g. way/1361881992 , way/1361881766)
3. Overlapping water areas. (e.g. way/1361881743 , way/1361881859 , way/1361881987)
4. Deprecated tagging leftover. (e.g. way/1361881987 )
5. Duplicate place=*: node/12609014267
6. Duplicate natural=water on nodes (e.g. node/12608030522 , node/12606175009)
7. Relation with only a source tag: relation/18736805
8. Duplicate nodes (e.g. node/2442258591 , node/12608016044)

Most of the above are only examples of each issue (the first few I came across). There are likely more examples out there as well as more issues; I only looked at a few small areas which you imported.
Unfortunately, importing Canvec isn't quite as simple as just uploading the data to OSM. There's a lot of prep work, conflation, validation, and cleanup that has to go into it.

Happy Mapping,
jmarchon

162724573 10 months ago

Welcome to OSM and thanks for getting this updated!
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/162724573

140658074 10 months ago

Oh yeah, it's wonderful. I probably used it here too, going off the tag "source=Bing; DOGAMI Lidar" on the changeset. Thank you though :-)

162552550 10 months ago

Welcome to OSM and thanks for getting this restaurant added!

162315343 10 months ago

I think this is the train station here? relation/10336724

162328159 10 months ago

Oops, thanks for catching my mistake!

162315343 10 months ago

Looks to me like you added a duplicate here. Would you mind taking another look?

162230338 11 months ago

Something went wrong here - the changeset comment here was supposed to say "Canvec 024G01-02".

162145606 11 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

162151456 11 months ago

Welcome back to OSM!