Hi Rajaneeshp,

place=pudussery GP is not a valid place value, could you check it out?

Also please be precise with your edits. You sometimes added "canalpiriv padasekaram", other times "canalpirivpadasekaram".

Also I saw you used https://maps.gov.ge/ as source in some of your edits. OSM have a strict policy about imports and licenses: osm.wiki/Import/ODbL_Compatibility

The only reference I can see about copyright in the Georgian Government website is "© 2014 საქართველოს მთავრობა". Therefore their data is under copyright. Do you have any information (which I didn't find) about that data being open and compatible to OSM or any special permission to use it?

Hi yusufmert,

I keep noticing some problems in your changesets.

For example you're adding a lot of fictional gardens in Tbilisi. This changeset is just an example of many.

Please read the wiki, a leisure=garden in OSM is: "a distinguishable planned space, usually outdoors, set aside for the display, cultivation, and enjoyment of plants and other forms of nature."

This is not the case, and it's clearly visible from the imagery you used (Maxar Premium Imagery). I think it would be better to delete them (together with the fictional forests you also mapped).

--------------

Here you added an extra relation: relation/13970573

it's not needed, this relation was enough: relation/13970574

I see iD tried to warn you ("warnings:missing_role"), a good practice would be to solve every warning before uploading a changeset in the database.

--------------

way/1044428178/history

Here you added a layer=-1 without specifying why. It's a building passage? Then the layer=-1 should be replace with "tunnel=building_passage" and added only to the part passing under the building.

Hi A-U-X,

I know it's a 3 years old changeset, but I'm struggling understanding this tagging:

relation/9597147/history

here there's a level tag but no building:levels tag.
Also is tagged level=3;7 (it means the church is located from the third floor to the seventh floor, what about 0-3 floors?). Also it has a building in the middle that is level=5 (way/690660242/history), this means there's a building only at floor five. But let's say it's probably a typo for building:levels, this is still strange since from pictures it looks like a tower, so it shouldn't be lower than the rest of the building (which arrives to the seventh floor based on the tagging).

Can you help me understand it?

Hi Miroslav,

relation/12410221/history

I'm not sure, but I think you added a place=* tag instead of a from=* one, could you check it out please?

Hi CupCakeDoo,

what's the difference between
fuel:octane_95_euro and fuel:octane_95_euro ?

Hi carfog81,

"wikipedia:es=Monumento_a_la_Resistencia"

should be wrote without underscores and with the language code in the value instead than in the tag when it's the only Wikipedia tag, such as:

"wikipedia=es:Monumento a la Resistencia"

also I think "artist_name" fits better here than "architect" (which contains a typo)

Good mapping :)

Ciao Alessandro, grazie per le aggiunte e benvenuto su OSM!

Solo un appunto, ho visto che hai inserito l'indirizzo sia come nodo che come tag dell'edificio.

In Italia per convenzione non aggiungiamo questi dati agli edifici ma come nodi in corrispondenza dell'ingresso o del numerino del civico. Inoltre sempre per convenzione scriviamo i civici così "49b" invece di "49/B".

Buon mapping!

Ciao Franco, benvenuto su OSM!

per i sampietrini penso sia piu' adatto surface=sett

surface=sett

buon mapping! :)

Ciao brustone,

vedo che hanno già corretto ma senza avvisarti: i nomi utilizzati dai biker vanno inseriti col tag name:mtb=*, non name=*

Inoltre non è necessario inserire bicycle, foot and horse=yes in combinazione con highway=path, questi valori sono impliciti.

Buon mapping :)

Ciao NikoMs90, benvenuto su OSM!

Ho dei piccoli consigli:

way/1042658475

bicycle=yes e foot=yes si possono evitare, sono impliciti in highway=path, puoi vedere i valori impliciti qua: osm.wiki/OSM_tags_for_routing/Access_restrictions#Italy

way/1042691113

Se questa è una scalinata dovrebbe essere highway=steps

way/1042691943

Qua ci sono due tag in conflitto, tracktype=grade2 indica una strada non asfaltata, ma il tag surface è =paved (asfaltato).

Per i numeri telefonici c'è un format da seguire che è =+<country code> <area code> <local number>

Buon mapping :)

Hi gio,

I'm noticing some mistakes in your changesets.

way/23560556

here you added wikidata=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levan_Mikeladze

The tag is wikidata, while the link is wikipedia.

Also the wikipedia value should be "=en:Levan Mikeladze" instead of "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levan_Mikeladze"

Also the "wikipedia" tags should be used for pages describing the element. This is not the case (the element is a street, the page is about a person). In this cases you should use the tag name:etymology:wikipedia=*

way/125337477

I don't think is right to add the layer=-1 to the whole street. You should have just fixed the part passing through the building.

way/34627216

tracktype=grade3 is to be used with highway=track. Also grade3 describes an unpaved track, while this highway is mapped as "surface"="paved".

Let me know if you have doubts / needs help.

Hi yusufmert,

way/1042701568

I don't think a couple of urban trees make this a forest.

way/1043111060/history

mapping this area as amenity=school creates TWO schools, since one is already mapped as node, see: osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element

You could tag it with landuse=education instead. And again, I don't think connecting landuses to highway is correct, half-highway does NOT belong to the landuse of the school.

I already tried to open a discussion about this topic here:

changeset/118673583

but I got no reply, I will try with an automated translation to Turkish in this one

----------------------------------------

Merhaba yusufmert,

way/1042701568

Birkaç şehir ağacının burayı orman yapacağını sanmıyorum.

way/1043111060/history

bu alanı amenity=school olarak eşlemek İKİ okul oluşturur, çünkü biri zaten düğüm olarak eşlenir, bkz.: osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element

Bunun yerine landuse=education ile etiketleyebilirsiniz. Ve yine, arazi kullanımlarını karayoluna bağlamanın doğru olduğunu düşünmüyorum, yarı otoyol okulun arazi kullanımına AİT DEĞİLDİR.

Bu konu hakkında burada bir tartışma açmaya çalıştım:

changeset/118673583

ama cevap alamadım bu sefer otomatik türkçe çeviri ile deneyeceğim

Hi Anindita,

way/969703936/history

you changed the value to place=village to a more generic place=yes, why?

Hi kaliphe,

I think you added the name as place value here: way/1042519909/history

could you check it out please?

StreetComplete chiede:

"Questa strada ha una banchina?

La banchina è una zona delimitata da una linea che permette ai veicoli di fermarsi in sicurezza al di fuori della carreggiata, può anche essere non completamente asfaltata."

maybe you forgot to reply, any news? I see you're still active (last CS from 3 hours ago)

Hi PRACTik, welcome to OSM :)

tienda=telas is not a valid tag. OSM tags are by convention in british english, what you wanted to describe with this tag?

Ciao xplosionmind,

un tip: per i contatti facebook non si usa il tag website ma contact:facebook=*

Inoltre diet:non-vegetarian=yes puoi tranquillamente evitarlo in quando superfluo ed implicito in diet:vegetarian=yes. Ogni diet:vegetarian=yes è automaticamente anche non-vegetarian, in caso contrario sarebbe diet:vegetarian=only.

Ciao Keio,

benvenuto su OSM!
Un tip: il tag building=* indica la funzione per cui l'edificio è stato creato (che non sempre coincide con l'uso attuale). Il tag per mappare un hotel è "tourism=hotel".

Buon mapping! :)