Hi Ching'en,

place=playground is not a valid place value, maybe you wanted to use leisure=playground?

It depends on the "use" of those places.

way/297276989/history

this for example seems from aerial images a parking for those terraced house? I would tag that area as amenity=parking. But this from aerial images, you have local knowledge (I think?)

way/430648332/history

I don't know about this one. But the highway should definitely be continuous.

By the way, as far as I now highway on areas is common only with pedestrian. highway=pedestrian+area=yes is a place where you can move in every direction (like a pedestrian square). Other highway can be rappresented by areas with area:highway=*

Hi BillyyyN,

welcome to OSM :)

A general recommendation is to keep changesets local, read: osm.wiki/Changeset#Geographical_size_of_changesets

I opened a random edits and I have some doubts.

You changed Coalville (node/26701457) from place=town to historic=boundary_stone

You created a Bile Settlement boundary but the Bile place node (node/1150885677/history) is located outside of it
could you check these out?

If you have questions ask without any problems, if you want you can join a Telegram OSM group (there's an international one and an African one as well)

good mapping :)

Ciao Davide,

ti avevo già scritto qua: changeset/124737209

ma forse non hai letto quindi ripropongo:
la sintassi per il tag wikimedia commons è "wikimedia_commons=File:Palo con tabelle Bivio D20 - Forcoletta.jpg" e non "wikimedia_commons=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Palo_con_tabelle_Bivio_D20_-_Forcoletta.jpg"

Buon mapping :)

Hi reinep,

I don't think place=yes is the proper tag for way297276989 and way430648332,
could you check it out please?

Good mapping :)

Hi OSMoz,

I think you forgot to define the place value here: node/9950771994

Good mapping :)

Hi albertoq,

what's the source of this edit? Seems like an import, or you visited 124 car repair shops asking for payment methods? Seems more like an import. You have been asked for the source of your edits twice already, in changeset/123243916 and changeset/101355648.

Also you have 37 changeset with comments from at least 12 different users, you didn't replied once.

Also please use a meaningful changeset comment, "Datos Completos" doens't other users understand what you have done. You have been asked to do so twice already, in changeset/123094716 and changeset/81753515.

Also there's no need to add [email protected] to ever element you added, your edits are already connected to your username via the element history. If the source of the data you add comes from your surveys you can add source=survey in the changeset source.

Hi,

since I noticed your still active
and
that you never replied to changeset comments (included comments regarding the same issues I wrote in this one, eg. changeset/101206529):

I deleted the non-specific tags myself.

I kept:
wheelchair=yes and internet_access=no even if I doubt you surveyed every single bank.

And ref:vatin=VEJ309841327+phone:call_center=0500-2635000 even if I have the same doubts.

Good mapping

Since you're still active but didn't replied I changed them with taxon:wikidata=Q129324

Good mapping

Hi Alberto, I notice some problems.

You added the same tags to several elements, while those tags should refere to the specific element.

For example you added the same image (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/39/Fachada_de_la_Torre_BNC_El_Rosal.png/330px-Fachada_de_la_Torre_BNC_El_Rosal.png) to 90 elements, while of course that building can correspond to only one of them. You also added "wikipedia=es:Banco Nacional de Crédito" to the same elements, again the wikipedia tag should refere to the specific element, in this case I think brand:wikipedia or operator:wikipedia fits better.

Same story for the youtube, instagram, facebook, linkedin tags.

And also the start_date, I don't think EVERY branch opened in the same day.

Hi Superadlen,

I don't think this is correct. The wikimedia_commons or image tag should be used for images representing the specific objects, not logos ecc, otherwise we would have the same image for every McDonald's and other shop chains.

The logo is already added in the NSI (https://nsi.guide/index.html?t=operators&k=amenity&v=post_office&tt=alg#algerieposte-e99ec0) as all others chains, I think is enough.

Do you agree?

Ciao Davide,

ricordati solo le prossime che la sintassi per il tag wikimedia commons è "wikimedia_commons=File:Postguide-Alpe Campo.jpg" e non "wikimedia_commons=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Postguide-Alpe_Campo.jpg"

Buon mapping :)

Hi mangofruit,

way/1051046161/history

what's the meaning of place=7?

Hi APneunzehn74,

thanks for you edits, just two notes:
the correct syntax for wikimedia commons is "wikimedia_commons=File:Windrose mit Windnamen.jpg", not "wikimedia_commons https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b9/Windrose_mit_Windnamen.jpg".

Also please use description:de=* instead of description=* while adding descriptions in german outside Germany

good mapping :)

Ciao Habib Elyasi,

could you check this nodes?

The place value is not a valid one, also you added a tag with a non-lating alphabet which is not standard in OSM (british english is used).

Hi kdbsm,

please stop adding "name:en=Drinking Water" as a name. We don't use descriptive names in OSM. Use the name tag only if the object have a proper name.

Hi, I see you're still active, any news? As it is now is something understable to you only, if I will not get a reply I will considere deleting them.

Ciao Alessio,

mi sembra ci sia un po' di confusione sulla provinciale, ora in alcune parti si chiama "Strada Provinciale 596 dei Cairoli", in altre (way/79560312) "SP596", un'altra parte ancora "SS596 dei Cairoli", e ancora "SS596". Hai cambiato un ref da "SPexSS596" a "SS596" mentre un altro ref lo hai cambiato da "SS596" a "SP596". Una gran confusione insomma.

Qua: way/1083630381

hai creato un edificio gigante che in realtà non c'è. iD ha anche provato ad avvisarti che si intersecava con una strada ma tu hai solo cliccato il suggerimento proposto aggiungendo un layer=1 al tutto.

Per favore fai piu' attenzione quando editi. Se hai domande ti segnalo che esiste un gruppo Telegram dove altri utenti possono aiutarti.

Buon mapping

Il rispetto non lo si ottiene sicuramente minacciando di segnalare per vandalismo gli utenti che modificano seguendo le linee guida della comunità.

Vedo ora che 5 minuti fa hai modificato l'alt_name di una via avente nome proprio (Via Ieranto) mettendogli come valore il ref del sentiero che passa di lì. Anche in quel caso è errato, dubito che un vicano si riferisca a Via Ieranto come "351" e venga compreso da altri vicani in riferimento a quella specifica via. I ref sono ref, non sono nomi così come non sono nomi alternativi.

Se pensate abbia torto aprite una discussione in mailing list, che è una delle "sedi opportune" in cui discute la comunità di OpenStreetMap.

Le modifiche di Mik05 non sono state scortesia verso nessun mapper, anzi ha ragione lui: i ref dei sentieri non sono nomi alternativi del sentiero. Come ha detto Mik05 i ref dei sentieri vanno nella relazione type=route, non sulle way.

Inoltre non si mappa per il rendering ("a beneficio degli escursionisti che vedono il nome dei sentieri sulle app"): osm.wiki/IT:Tagging_for_the_renderer