OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
132539381 almost 3 years ago

> Well I'm the owner of the data and the one who is responsible for it and I have the right to redistribute it

Cool, then you can easily document this on the OSM Wiki officially, which is the first step for an import!

121410757 almost 3 years ago

Da liegst hier völlig richtig.
Der `mini_roundabout` node/283213096/history wurde aber vor +10 Jahren von jemand anderem erfasst, ich habe den vor 9 Monaten bei einer Ausrichtungsaktion nur chli bewegt.
Auf https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/mini-roundabout/7524 gab es letzthin eine seeeehr lange Diskussion dazu, fokussiert auf Deutschland (wenn ich richtig liege, habe nicht alles gelesen ;) )

Du erwähnst 'Verkehrberuhigungsmassnahme', was meinst du, den Kreuzungs-Knoten als `traffic_calming=hump` taggen ( traffic_calming=hump )?

132539381 almost 3 years ago

> the source of data is an official website for postal codes and building from the ministry of telecommunication in Palestine

- Are you allowed to import this data in OSM? Freely available data is not necessarily data that OpenStreetMap is allowed to redistribute globally.
- Did you follow the import guidelines specified here: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Import
- Did you document this import somewhere?
- Did you discuss this with the (local) community?
- Are you taking care to conflate this data with already present buildings?

If all these questions are answered with yes, then we would not have this discussion *here*.

117936643 almost 3 years ago

Super, Mersi!

132539381 almost 3 years ago

Rawad, as I’m living in middle Europe I know far to less to comment anything about politics; I just saw that your import here is completely wrong in regards to how the complete OSM community everywhere maps buildings.
You introduce undocumented key/value combinations like status=P, type=V, model= connect.building.
Other keys like number_of_apartments are modeled as `building:flats` in OSM.
area_m2 Is completely useless, as it can be calculated from the data.
Additionally you simply dumped your data over already existing data, essentially duplicating already present data (albeit with worse geometry).

What’s the source of your data; is OpenStreetMap legally allowed to globally provide it under the ODBL?

It is these things that struck my eye, not where on the globe they happened!

132539381 almost 3 years ago

As zstadler said, you need to follow the process outlined in osm.wiki/Import, namely discussing it with the local community.

132668659 almost 3 years ago

Once the tiles are rendered, you clean your cache and you reload them map.
It’s visible for me.

132668659 almost 3 years ago

Move was done in changeset/132694292

132694292 almost 3 years ago

Because of discussion in changeset/132668659

132668659 almost 3 years ago

It seems that the exact position of the peak node/5523504160 is not correct.

I moved it to the exact position of the 'x' on https://map.geo.admin.ch/?lang=en&topic=ech&bgLayer=ch.swisstopo.pixelkarte-farbe&layers=ch.swisstopo.zeitreihen,ch.bfs.gebaeude_wohnungs_register,ch.bav.haltestellen-oev,ch.swisstopo.swisstlm3d-wanderwege,ch.astra.wanderland-sperrungen_umleitungen&layers_opacity=1,1,1,0.8,0.8&layers_visibility=false,false,false,false,false&layers_timestamp=18641231,,,,&E=2577028.14&N=1158300.74&zoom=11.63192809488736

132668659 almost 3 years ago

I misunderstood you; I aligned the *path* and moved it slightly to the south, which you can see if you zoom in here: https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=132668659

132356548 almost 3 years ago

Unfortunately, large zoom levels are not rendered very quickly, i.e. the vandalism will still be viewable for a bit. But the data is gone, so it's only a matter of time...

132539381 almost 3 years ago

ciao zstadler

I also stumbled over this user, because of changeset/132588076 in which they produced an Osmose error on one of my armchair mapping sessions where I've added way/1110231096/

Did you report them to the DWG already?

132588076 almost 3 years ago

Ciao Rawad
You've duplicated a *lot* of buildings in this changeset, specifically in the region of way/433072629/
I honestly think this changeset should simply be reverted and done again, properly.
Greetings from Switzerland,
habi

PS: I'm here because of way/1110231096/ which I've added some months ago and one building you've added here overlaps these stairs.
https://osmose.openstreetmap.fr complained about an error in *my* map edits, which I'd like to fix :)

132615946 almost 3 years ago

Ooops!
Sorry für den geographic grossen Änderungssatz.
Ein paar JOSM-Fehlerwaren noch in der Region um Gümmenen, während ich wegen der Notiz in Nidwalden editierte...

131392273 almost 3 years ago

"Save your work before moving across the globe" is my insight :)
Happy mapping!

132286821 almost 3 years ago

👌🏼

132012580 almost 3 years ago

"Lauben" spezifisch mit covered=arcade, ansonsten einfach mit `covered=yes`

131305662 almost 3 years ago

👌🏼, das könntest/solltest du im Kommentar angeben.
Lädst du die Daten als Hintergrund in iD, oder schaust du das in zwei Browser-Fenster?

131915781 almost 3 years ago

Einzelne Änderungen nur einzeln, manuell. Dies am einfachsten in JOSM.

Ein ganzer Änderungssatz kann mit http://revert.osmz.ru/ rückgängig gemacht werden, aber das ist die grobe Holzhammer-Methode.