OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
162507325 7 months ago

Might I direct you towards the copyright terms on landdirect.ie which you will find under "Terms and Conditions":
"Copyright
16. Save where otherwise appearing, the material provided through landdirect.ie is subject to Tailte Éireann copyright in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 (No. 28 of 2000).
17. Permission to reproduce Government copyright material does not extend to any material on this site which may be the property of a third party. Authorisation to reproduce such material must be obtained from the copyright holders concerned.
18. Land Registry digital maps accessible through the landdirect.ie service and the aerial photographs which may be viewed online incorporate Ordnance Survey Ireland (OSi) mapping data and ortho-photography respectively, under a licence from OSi. © OSi and Government of Ireland.
19. landdirect.ie also incorporates information licensed from GeoDirectory, a product developed by An Post and © GeoDirectory."

It's not OSM who decided to make this not open data; that was the Irish government. So please delete the data from OSM, unless you have a waiver from Táilte Éireann, Eircodefinder and An Post.

Thank you for mapping the buildings and house numbers - hoping you got the house numbers from the doors.

134557035 7 months ago

If you got them from the individuals, please add `source:addr:postcode=local knowledge (resident)` or something like that, so we know it's not manually imported from eircode finder.

134557035 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes on the houses in Killyduff? You may not copy eircodes from the eircode finder onto OSM, because that data is not open and thus not compatible with the ODB license on OpenStreetMap. Unless you found them displayed on the individual houses/ gates/ fences or got them from the house owners/ residents (in that case, pls add `source:addr:postcode` to the houses), please delete them.

162669066 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes on the houses in Kilcarn Woods? You may not copy eircodes from eircode finder into OSM, because their data is copyrighted and not compatible with the open data license used on OpenStreetMap. Unless you found them displayed on each individual house/ gate/ fence or talked to each individual house owner (in that case, add `source:addr:postcode` to each individual house), please delete them.

118170875 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes on Belpere Road? You may not copy eircodes from the eircode finder into OSM, because it is copyrighted material whose license is not compatible with the open data license on OSM. Unless you found them publicly displayed on each individual house/ gate/ fence or talked to each individual house owner (in that case, add `source:addr:postcode` to each house), please delete them.

50379828 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes added on St Seachnail's Road? You cannot copy eircodes from the eircodefinder into OSM, because it is copyrighted material which is not compatible with the open data license used on OSM. Unless they are displayed on each individual house/ gate/ fence or you got them from each individual house owner (in that case add that as `source:addr:postcode`, please delete them.

38680166 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes on the buildings? You may not copy eircodes from the eircodefinder, since it is copyrighted material that does not match the requirements for the open data license used by OpenStreetmap. Unless you found the eircode publicly displayed on each individual house/ gate/ fence or talked to every individual house owner, please delete them.

40607413 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes at Clareville and in Garrafrauns? You cannot copy eircodes from eircodefinder, since it is not open data as required by the ODBL license OSM uses. If they are displayed on the house/ gate/ fence or you talked to the individual house owners, please add that source to the buildings.

162507325 7 months ago

What is your source for the eircodes here? You know you cannot copy them from eircodefinder, right? You don't give the source on either the individual houses nor in the changeset comment. Unless they are displayed on the house/ fence/ gate or you got them from each individual house owner, please delete them. Add the sources, if you didn't get them from eircodefinder, please.

165638818 8 months ago

Alright, EveryDoor wasn't able to do that, but should be fixed now.

116905738 8 months ago

You're probably right. If you look closely at the shadows of the animals on Bing, they look like horses.

156564960 8 months ago

I can't remember ever going into Champion Sports, but H&M and TKMAxx definitely have two levels, so I presume that's what's meant there.

97720437 8 months ago

I've fixed the relation, but I don't know which part has how many levels, if you want to add that.

90131370 9 months ago

should be fixed now.

89794322 9 months ago

You're right, as far as I remember it's a one-storey former dairy or something.

160829812 9 months ago

Hi Brian, this contains a broken relation (13285410) now.

162260937 9 months ago

Thanks for bringing those to my attention. They should be fixed now.

163839458 9 months ago

I've made some adjustments, but they are on Bing and Esri.

137187855 9 months ago

Yes, they can. I have been in a car driven from William Street around the corner into Garden Row and out Friary Street. Frightening, but possible.

163928398 9 months ago

I just came upon this as well, looks very wrong. Should be reverted asap, bc it'll wreak havoc with sat navs.