OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
27934901 almost 6 years ago

Hallo schoschi,
du hast in diesem Changeset bei einigen Objekten eine teilweise vorhandene Adresse gelöscht. Das ist leider nicht sonderlich sinnvoll. Besser wäre es, die Adressen zu vervollständigen. Ich habe das bei dem Gasthaus, neben einer Fehlerkorrektur, gemacht.
Gruß aquarix

80046803 almost 6 years ago

Hello luchaaker,
welcome to OpenStreetMap.
Please do me and other OSM contributors a favor and do not upload edits across continents. This makes it complicated to check and it is also not very clear.
Better make many smaller changes than a few large ones.
Regards aquarix

80051892 almost 6 years ago

Hello seearctic,
I've reviewed your changeset.
It's basically OK but a house that is normally a rectangle only needs 4 nodes, not 6. I have changed this and added the building next to it which could be a garage.
If you have further information about it, you can also add this to the object. See building=garage
Regards aquarix

79815327 almost 6 years ago

Hello,
I would agree with freebeer that this changeset is trivial to review because the number of objects is small.
Nevertheless for the sake of clarity it would be better to edit in one country, upload the changes and then move on to another country or region.
I have already seen enough examples where changesets at continent size contain hundreds of objects and such are horrible to review.
Regards aquarix

79742839 almost 6 years ago

Hallo jngt,
beim OZMO ist dir ein Zahlendreher bei der Tel. Nr. passiert (0 mit 9 vertauscht). Das hab ich korrigiert. Siehe changeset/79744262
Gruß aquarix

79733498 almost 6 years ago

Hallo lukfunk,
für einen Änderungssatz der sich rund um einen Fußweg dreht ist die Umgrenzunglinie arg groß geraten. Die Änderung im Oman sollte vmtl. nicht dazugehören.
Wenn man eh schon weiß, dass man etwas ändert, das sich in einem anderen Teil der Welt befindet bitte einfach gleich hochladen bevor man daheim weiter mappt.
Gruß aquarix

79737377 almost 6 years ago

Hallo jngt,
könntest du bitte darlegen, warum du bei allen Apotheken bis auf eine die PLZ und den Ort entfernt hast?

Wenn jedes Haus, das den Knoten umschließt, eine vollständige Adresse hätte, oder wenn die Tags auf "contact:*" umgeschrieben würden, könnte man das ja noch durchgehen lassen. So aber sehe ich das an der Grenze zum Vandalismus, weil gültige Daten "einfach so" entfernt wurden.
PLZ + Ort sind jedenfalls keine ungültigen Redundanzen.
Gruß aquarix

79737378 almost 6 years ago

Da der München-Ticket Schalter nicht die gleichen Öffnungszeiten hat wie der Fahrkartenschalter, habe ich das behelfsweise mal so eingetragen:
osm.wiki/Tag:opening_hours:München-Ticket=...
Siehe auch Forums Diskussion: https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=68474

78624110 about 6 years ago

Hello Nolebring,
welcome to OpenStreetMap.
Just a small note regarding your changeset.
It is good practice to add regionally related changes to the map together.
This means that objects located in another country or continent should be added separately in a new change set.
Best regards aquarix

77934107 about 6 years ago

Hallo SWF8,
auch wenn du nur kleine Änderungen machst, einen kurzen Kommentar solltest du dennoch dazu schreiben. In dem Fall z. B. "Haltestelle umgebaut". Das erleichtert dir selber und anderen nachzuvollziehen was im Changeset geändert wurde.
Gruß aquarix

77536049 about 6 years ago

Hello StephaneP,
I would like you limit your changesets to a smaller region. If you want to delete the "is_in" tag, you could do this per country or region.
If you do this over several continents at once it looks like a mechanical edit for me.
Regards aquarix

77411243 about 6 years ago

Hello nicolas_bellemans,
welcome to OpenStreetMap.
Please do other OSM contributors a favour and narrow your changesets to a certain region. In this case you added items on three different continents. Normally you only edit items in only one country per changeset. This makes quality assurance a lot easier.
Regards aquarix

75048302 about 6 years ago

Hello Bence Mélykúti,
it would be better if you first commit the POIs in Freiburg and then on other places.
Changes in several countries at once are not so welcome.
The same is true in changeset/76615128.
Regards aquarix

77246666 about 6 years ago

Hello James Dovell,
welcome to OSM.
I have an annotation to your commit. Please do other contributors of OSM a favor and upload your changes before you travel to another continent.
In this case the bounding box spans over Africa and Asia though it has nothing to do with it. When you split into two commits, one per region, everything is OK.
Regards aquarix

77069113 about 6 years ago

Hallo PelzM,
willkommen bei OSM.
Frage: Was heißt denn "übung if hm"?
Aus dem Kommentar sollte ersichtlich sein, was geändert wurde. Siehe osm.wiki/DE:Good_changeset_comments
Gruß aquarix

76970596 about 6 years ago

Hello JACKenY,
welcome to OpenStreetMap.
Please respect a few rules here in the OSM project.
One of them is to change not more than one country per changeset.
As far as I can see the bounding box spans about four continents and a dozen countries.
Additionally you should provide useful changeset comments to give other people an idea of what you have changed. "voila" as a comments isn't really helpful.
Please read through this article: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
One more tip: Start small and map in your area first. There you can more easily check if a condition is really as it looks on the aerial photo. After a few years there are many places that are no longer up to date.
Regards aquarix

76871066 about 6 years ago

OK, I have to admit that I wasn't aware that oneway=yes is implied. Again what learned. No offense.
But as it's not wrong to add it, Osmose would be wrong if it reports an error for this case.
Regards aquarix

76871066 about 6 years ago

Hello Ferdinand0101,
If you're using Osmose you should follow the same rules as when using iD or any other editor. Stay at a region and don't run around half the world.
Secondly referring to the roundabout you changed in Ireland: Why you removed the one-way? I haven't heard about a roundabout where you can go both directions. So please correct this error.
Regards aquarix

76871806 about 6 years ago

Hello Ferdinand0101,
I'm not sure how this is handled in other countries in OSM but as far as I know you should avoid abbreviations.
See this Wiki article: osm.wiki/Names#Abbreviation_.28don.27t_do_it.29
So I think you should revert your change.
Regards aquarix

41114864 about 6 years ago

Hello hjasuer,
I haven't been on this island, yet but what you entered as "name=" is surely not the real name. This is more like a description.
Additionally in a foreign country you should use the local language for the "name=" tag. Otherwise you should use a language suffix like "name:de=" or "description:de=" if you don't know how to write in the local language.
Third: you always should give a short summary about what you've changed. E.g. in this case: added a bakery.
See this Wiki article for further information: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Regards aquarix