OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
71726442 over 6 years ago

Hello merlwinisop,
welcome to the OpenStreetMap community.
I have a comment to this change record. You have edited in several countries. This by itself is a good thing but please commit your changes in one country before starting to edit in another country. This is more friendly for quality assurance and makes the changes well arranged.
Please also have a look at this Wiki article osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments because nobody can imagine what you have changed if you simply write "ok".
Regards aquarix

71593605 over 6 years ago

Hallo Toni,
dass es hier keine Haltestelle mehr gibt stimmt, zumindest gibt es keine H Tafel mehr.
Das Wartehäuschen steht aber schon noch da. Zumindest war das am 8. Juni noch so. Da hab ich nämlich den Hydranten nebenan eingezeichnet.
Ob das im Zuge der Bauarbeiten für den Kreisel abgerissen wird weiß ich aber nicht.
Gruß aquarix

71539517 over 6 years ago

I didn't mean no offence with my comment.
I have looked at the changes in Canada a little bit and found nothing conspicuous about it. I'm just surprised that according to OSM something was changed in China but I didn't find the element.
Would it be conceivable that there is a bug in "Go Map"or in OSM backend that leads to such effects? I once accidentally uploaded an element from which I deleted my change before uploading. In OSM this was still displayed as changed.
Regards aquarix

71539517 over 6 years ago

Hello badenk,
it would be nice if you would edit only in one country per changeset. Recently you have created three changesets that span from Canada to China. That makes it difficult to review what you have actually changed and it's not very polite to other mappers. So please have that in mind in the future.
Best regards aquarix

71537702 over 6 years ago

Hallo Nikolas von Randow,
aus welcher Quelle hast du die Information, dass die Tankstelle in Antholing Mitglied im "Bundesverband freier Tankstellen" ist?
Soweit ich weiß ist nicht jede Tankstelle, die zu keiner der großen Marken gehört automatisch dort Mitglied.
Außerdem wäre es schön, wenn du im Änderungssatz noch einen kurzen Kommentar hinterlegen würdest, damit andere Leute eine Idee davon haben was du geändert hast und nicht erst jedes Element einzeln anschauen müssen. Danke
Gruß aquarix

71108223 over 6 years ago

Hello venza,
please avoid committing changes that are thousands of kilometres distant from each other. This makes changesets unclear. Thank you
Regards aquarix

71138356 over 6 years ago

Hallo lenz42,
willkommen bei OpenStreetMap.
Bitte gewöhne dir an, dass du deine Änderungen mit einem kurzen Kommentar versiehst, damit andere Leute eine Vorstellung haben was du geändert hast. Wenn du mehrere ähnliche Änderungen vornimmst kannst du den gleichen Kommentar auch mehrfach verwenden.
Im OSM Wiki ist das auch gut beschrieben: osm.wiki/DE:Good_changeset_comments
Viel Spaß weiterhin.
Gruß aquarix

71129462 over 6 years ago

Hello Tallerinnovacion1,
welcome to OpenStreetMap. I have some annotations to this changeset.
1st: please commit your changes more granular. Items in Greenland normally have nothing to do with items in India. So simply split your changes per country.
2nd: What should the way way/696325245 in Greenland be? You have assigned no properties to it. The same is true for way way/696325240. Please either remove it or assign proper key/value pairs.
3rd: On way way/696325244 you have assigned nonsensical attributes as
campo de minas bum bum explosion
Please search the wiki osm.wiki/How_to_map_a for suitable values or remove the way. If you don't find what you need you also can ask in https://forum.openstreetmap.org
4th: Please add a meaningful comment to your changes that other mappers can understand what you have changed.
Best regards aquarix

71050036 over 6 years ago

Hello pyrog,
please group your changes by country if you do an adjustment like this the next time. To be precise the node/5759953725 is in Japan, the others are in Europe as far as I can see.
Please keep an eye on this in the future. Thank you.
Regards aquarix

70974505 over 6 years ago

Hello again,
after taking a closer look at some of your changes, I must have misunderstood something. I thought it was about the country, but it's more about the language. Please forget what I wrote about the changeset comments.
Regards aquarix

70974505 over 6 years ago

Hello,
if you name a changeset like "Name(s) in Macedonian" you should only include things from Macedonia but nowhere else.
Second: Please give your changes a meaningful comment. Each time the same comment has no added value.
Please see this Wiki article: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Regargs aquarix

70823631 over 6 years ago

Hello Marc Konjuhi,
if you name a changeset as "Updates in Kosovo" you should commit changes in Kosovo only. If you do changes in Düsseldorf too, you should commit them separately.
Please keep an eye on it in the future. Thank you.
Regards aquarix

70940041 over 6 years ago

Hello pkoby,
thank you for fixing osmose errors. Just one thing: Please do the fixes more regional. In this case you have done changes around the world and this makes things unclear if the changes bounding box includes half of the world. You should not include more than one country in a changeset. If you're unsure, there is a function in JOSM that allows you to upload the current selection only instead of all changes.
Regards aquarix

70666234 over 6 years ago

Das scheint wohl tatsächlich zu stimmen weil weiter nördlich gibt es auch noch Hydranten mit ähnlich großen Durchmesserangaben. Da läuft wohl eine enorm dicke Hauptwasserleitung durch den Wald.

70689163 over 6 years ago

Hello 🇨🇿 Roman Horník,
please provide a short comment in your changes that other people have an idea what you have changed.
Please see this explanation in the Wiki: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Thank you very much.
Regards aquarix

70674802 over 6 years ago

Hello,
it would be nice if you could split your changesets into smaller regional changes. One change should not exceed one country. In this case it ranges over three continents and one ocean. Please remember that in the future. Thank you very much.
Regards aquarix

70666234 over 6 years ago

Hallo,
ich schätze mal bei dem einen Hydrant im Wald ist eine 0 zu viel. Ich kenne jedenfalls keine Bauart mit 1 m Durchmesser. ;-)
Gruß aquarix

70502734 over 6 years ago

Hello whalerich, if you changeset is covering such a large area it is seen in the local history of many users, although there is no change in the area of the user.
What I'm saying is it's just a bad style to make changes all over the world and then upload them as a single change. This is all the more true when these changes have no direct relation to each other.
A set of changes should cover a maximum of one country but not a number of continents.
Regards aquarix

70566273 over 6 years ago

Hello chexum, if you write "Details/buildings around Long Ashton" as your change comment, you only should upload changes in Britain. In this case you have a changeset bounding box over half middle Europe. People from e.g. Austria shouldn't see it in their local history. Please have this in mind.
Thank you
aquarix

70466212 over 6 years ago

Ein Beispiel: amenity=public_building ist veraltet und sollte durch etwas anderes ersetzt werden. Siehe amenity=public_building