OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
174359636 about 1 month ago

why are there bbq's at the station exit?

174357562 about 1 month ago

the full length can be left, but the way can be split and tagged with access=private if there's no public access at all...

174357328 about 1 month ago

way/1448328912

I think if it's natural woodlands over a larger area but the nature of the trees there is that they are sparse then it's fine, but in a metro park or in this case a cemetery where there are graves underneath I think a natural=wood area like this is incorrect and mapping for the renderer, and it should be done via natural=tree nodes for each tree.

153889358 about 1 month ago

note/4971581 says there's no barrier where you added one, but no photo, so might need another survey....

174264405 about 1 month ago

I've removed the duplicate road, and split the original way where you describe the 50 limit change and set that for the town section. Feel free to take a look and improve if needed.

174264405 about 1 month ago

you've already set the speed limit on way/462198936 which is where it needs to be set.
way/1447829950 created a duplicate road

172778203 about 1 month ago

I've finished restoring the original highway ways here to retain the history osm.wiki/Good_practice#Keep_the_history and restore the lost tags (like maxspeed etc).

172774907 about 1 month ago

Bing imagery isn't aligned here, please check the GPS traces layer for alignment.

172773153 about 1 month ago

Bing imagery here has an offset, which needs to be accounted for if mapping against it, this can be checked via the GPS traces layer. Furthermore I believe service=alley was correct per service=alley

due to this I've reverted this changeset.

172778203 about 1 month ago

...also chiming in. It looks like you're trying to split roads into dual carriageways (two oneways) where they are physically split but in OSM they were previously mapped as a single two way, but in doing so many of the existing tags were lost and in some instances the original ways were deleted in place of new ways which looses the history. Is best to retain the existing ways for the history.

Furthermore enabling the GPS traces here it seems that Bing imagery has an offset and ESRI imagery is better aligned, but the ways have been mapped to match Bing.

Because of the lost way history I'll revert the problematic changes, we can continue to work on improvements from there.

174258562 about 1 month ago

how do you know the building height and building levels from aerial imagery?

174187954 about 2 months ago

In the iD editor there is a "Driveway" preset which should be used for driveways, the tags should be highway=service + service=driveway.

174214161 about 2 months ago

hi and welcome to OSM. The building outline should follow the building footprint instead of the property boundary. You can take a look at how other buildings nearby have been mapped to check.

173930028 about 2 months ago

I'm not sure the reason to remove historic=memorial here? I've reverted the changeset to restore it for now.

173930156 about 2 months ago

not sure what was wrong with this, but I've reverted this changeset in changeset/174187322 based on the reasons given in the changeset description

173956929 about 2 months ago

I've reverted this changeset since it appears to be related to a temporary event and per osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_temporary_events_and_temporary_features we don't map these kinds of temporary events in OSM.

174003821 about 2 months ago

the boundary=national_park tag is discouraged in Australia per the guidelines at osm.wiki/Australian_Tagging_Guidelines/Land_and_boundaries

We generally use boundary=protected_area in combination with protection_title=National Park to indicate the designation along with the protect_class tag.

174019497 about 2 months ago

it's good practice to keep the history as you edit features osm.wiki/Good_practice#Keep_the_history

this means instead of deleting something just to re-add it, it's best to adjust what's already there. this will depend on the situation, but in this case it would be better practice to try and fix the existing buildings.

174056939 about 2 months ago

It's also possible in JOSM to find the affected dragged nodes, look at their coordinates history and right click over the Latitude/Longitude text and choose "Restore".

Sometimes this can be easier than a selective revert where you do want to keep most of the other changes.

174180775 about 2 months ago

that's not pyramidal, it's hipped roof:shape=*