What's your source for that? Their website has it as Brighton Boulevard in Bondi Beach, not Hastings Parade in North Bondi.

See the addr:suburb and addr:city now conflict, we should just use one.

Sorry I meant "If you disagree with the station being mapped as an area..."

node deleted in changeset/77674070

If you disagree with the station being mapped as a node please join the discussion on the mailing list https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-au/2019-March/012428.html.

Per osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element we should just have one railway=station for Central station. I'll delete your node you just added again.

I've reinstated the building part as visible in the mapillary and aerial imagery.

I've converted this to one parking lot in changeset/77673515

railway=station accepts ways for railway=station and it's in widespread use with 9,000+ existing stations map as ways.

Further the wiki page says " railway=station should be applied to an area covering the whole station, or preliminary on a node placed at the center of the station area, from the passengers' point of view (i.e. near platforms)."

If you prefer a single node, you could take the centroid or pole of inaccessibility to get a node from the closed way.

As for where the boundary should be:

"While passengers only have the area around the station building and the platforms in mind, railway staff and railway enthusiasts think of the whole railway area which begins at the entry signal at one side and ends at the entry signals at the other side." so an area that covers the buildings, tracks, platforms, and extends to the surveyable station entrances and extends to the entry signal for trains is ideal. I agree that for the general public how far to extend along the tracks can be hard to determine, but I don't believe that means we should give up and only use a node.

I agree, the landuse says this is rail infrastructure, but we need to go further to say that all this land here is "Central" station.

I agree the relation which groups these features is very important as well, but I don't see how this means we can't also represent the station as an area.

I have no "service" or any other reason for preferring a polygon, it's simply that I believe the polygon is a more accurate representation of this feature than a point, and it's already well supported to be mapped as an area, and the fallback to a node is easy to implement downstream, so why not?

Start with the top level access `access:lanes=yes|yes|no` then specify who can use that last lane, so `psv:lanes=yes|yes|designated` + `bicycle:lanes=yes|yes|yes`.

PS. If in the JOSM editor, there a "Lanes" map style which shows the lane counts, turn lanes, access etc. styles on the map so gives good visual feedback.

way/174088858/history is a two way road, so it's lanes=2 not 1. Was that just a typo on your side?

I've added `psv:lanes=yes|yes|designated` to mark the right lane as a "bus lane". In my opinion `access:lanes=yes|yes|psv` is incorrect, since access=psv is incorrect.

Instead of MOE:years you could just use the grades tag, defined at amenity=school.

Looks good.

+1. but you can still place it in the loc_name tag if you like.

Thanks!

Hi I didn't hear back so I've reverted Central Station's railway=station back onto the area it covers.

What's "The Office"? Per name=* the name tag should just be the common default name, and per osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don.27t_use_name_tag_to_describe_things it shouldn't be used for a description.

If it's a local name best to put it in the local_name tag.

https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/node/2390154110
because you'd replaced it with the Homemaker Center mall which is already mapped at
way/554571579

If the butcher is in the wrong location, then best to drag the node to the correct location.

Hi welcome to OSM, I've cleaned up some of the overlapping ways here, and corrected the tagging to be a parking aisle.

It looks like this was just a temporary road for construction since in the latest Maxar imagery it's mostly just dirt now.

reverted in changeset/77600944