aharvey's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 62358025 | over 7 years ago | what does no=service here mean? |
| 62358039 | over 7 years ago | Unless these are open to the public to use, could you add access=private? |
| 62358264 | over 7 years ago | same issue here wrt bus=designated on nodes. |
| 62358301 | over 7 years ago | Could you hold off the mass change please? Manually changes are prefered as it's all too easy to make mistakes with mass changes. eg. https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/node/719962298 |
| 54531273 | over 7 years ago | I don't think we should be mapping people's backyard trampoline in OSM, they aren't fixed structures. Also see osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only |
| 62358945 | over 7 years ago | Re. https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/369623933 are you sure the whole road isn't called Mons Road, with the T-way route going on that road? What do the signs on the ground say? |
| 62359347 | over 7 years ago | PS. psv=yes is not needed on residential roads, public service vehicles are already assumed to be allow to drive on residential roads. |
| 62359347 | over 7 years ago | Is https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/26315574 really bus=designated? |
| 62359437 | over 7 years ago | You've (probably accidentally) added bus=designated to all the nodes on these ways, plus in your other changesets too I think. The the tags on the ways are sufficient. This can happen if you use select all in JOSM (not a good idea), best to manually select each to avoid accidentally tagging the wrong thing. |
| 62336680 | over 7 years ago | Hey, I assume you thought you were adding a private bookmark? Your change changed the name of this bus stop for everyone. |
| 62339040 | over 7 years ago | I've reverted the accidentally moved nodes due to https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/4776 |
| 62338762 | over 7 years ago | I've reverted the accidental moving of the pub. |
| 62338595 | over 7 years ago | Hi welcome to OSM! Thanks for the edit. It looks like you've accidentally dragged some other nodes https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/62338595. I've reverted those changes. When using the iD editor it's all to easy to accidentally drag nodes due to https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/4776 so you just need to be careful when panning the map around that you're not moving nodes, or use the JOSM editor instead. As for the path, what kind of path is it? Is it able to be driven on even if only by local council etc? See the description for paths at highway=* |
| 62338762 | over 7 years ago | Hi, oneway and lanes tags look good. See your change at https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/62338762 did you mean to move the pub? I've moved it back based on https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-33.87433360601114&lng=151.20527256261062&z=18.056516383010184&x=0.8987306939122932&y=0.47731137004967844&zoom=0.1012815316012496&pKey=4E2l1I6Qq2p3SkAqEUCCTA&focus=photo Also surface=asphalt is more specific than surface=paved, if it's not asphalt could you confirm which surface type it is? |
| 62339040 | over 7 years ago | Hi, just checking you did mean to move the toilets and Flight Center as well? See your change at https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/62339040 highway=footway implies motor_vehicle=no so it's not necessary to explicitly say. |
| 62326678 | over 7 years ago | I'd still say it's a driveway even if it's shared by multiple houses. It looks like it's an easement across all the properties, so access=private makes sense. |
| 62326678 | over 7 years ago | Hi you could also add service=driveway service=driveway and access=private (if it's not a public road) |
| 62281794 | over 7 years ago | Nitpicking but 1/10 should probably be addr:unit=1, addr:housenumber=10 |
| 62302087 | over 7 years ago | I've change the opening_hours format so it validates. http://projets.pavie.info/yohours/ and opening_hours=* can be helpful. |
| 62239966 | over 7 years ago | Thanks for confirming that. I've reverted this change, as it was correct before, access=no (as generally no one can access it) and then say who can, in this case busses acting in a public service vehicle, since it's designated and not just permitted for busses we should use bus=designated (slightly stronger than bus=yes). See access=* designated means "A preferred or designated route for the class of traffic specified by the tag key, such as foot=designated, in general this means that there is a (explicit) sign saying something like "pedestrians allowed", or a pedestrian icon." |