The church is called St Paul’s Church Colton.
It is. Church of England church and not a Methodist church.

http://www.allsaintsboltonpercy.co.uk/st-pauls-colton.php

Band Stand

Rowntree Cafe and Library

Small Tree Covered Island in Duck Pond

The Pig & Pastry (Best Cafe In York!)

Hotel 53 has now been replaced with a Holiday Inn (https://www.ihg.com/holidayinn/hotels/gb/en/york/qqyct/hoteldetail)

Local Press article suggests Tramways Club has shut.

"teddy bear store "
The place has gone or never existed. This is an auto-generated note from MAPS.ME application: a user reports a POI that is visible on a map (which can be outdated), but cannot be found on the ground.
POI has no name
POI types: building
OSM data version: 2017-11-17T20:18:02Z
#mapsme

"Please check for stonegate teddy bear store ,the shops are very compact so it may be difficult to identify all of them

"
POI name: Hotel Chocolat
POI types: shop-chocolate
OSM data version: 2017-11-17T20:18:02Z
#mapsme