OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
75331229 over 6 years ago

Hi,
Relation for Little Vanderlin Island (10118134, v1) draws errors..

First the 2 outers share segments.
Second the key natural should not have 2 values.

So I have remove the key natural from the island relation and made 2 new relations - one for sand the other for scrub.
I have corrected the island relation outer ways so they don't share segments.

75376938 over 6 years ago

Reverted.
Broken admin boundaries for Balmain and East Balmain.

74107436 over 6 years ago

No worries, fixed.

74107436 over 6 years ago

Comment ..
There is a lot of work to do in NZ.. see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=175.34514&lat=-39.87126&zoom=7

74107436 over 6 years ago

By combining the coastline this has made the whole Island a National Park....

One section of the coastline is used by the National Park as its boundary...

Coast line is now in 4 sections. It may be broken to more sections e.g. for use as a beach boundary or other things.

So now the coastline is a relation.

71502017 over 6 years ago

Hi,
As relation/9712537 Ball's Pyramid has only one member so this can be a simple way. I have changed this.

72837944 over 6 years ago

So the tag 'construction=rail' should be removed?

67710449 over 6 years ago

OSM tagging does not include "highway=tree_row" ... it does have "natural=tree_row".

73731788 over 6 years ago

way/718244634 etc tagged as road with fixme .. I would assume these to be residential - same as the development to the north - Bradman Dr. etc.

67710449 over 6 years ago

way/674047783 tagged as highway=tree_row ...

67700959 over 6 years ago

Umm the way/673977783 is tag as natural=water and highway=tree_row ???? err what is it?

72837944 over 6 years ago

Hi,
Using the LPI Imagery I cannot see a railway nor a bridge on way/698616096. The bridge is there on Maxar, but no railway.

72392357 over 6 years ago

Not visible in Bing, Maxar nor LPI imagery.

73741748 over 6 years ago

You tagged construction=primary on way/235283592 ?? Is this under construction? It is also tagged highway=primary that suggests it is in use.

75093141 over 6 years ago

Many 'paddocks' are rather large .. and may not have 'fencing'. Think of the 'paddocks' in central Australia... However in this area I would expect there to be some fencing to stop stock wandering on to roads.
There may not be stock in a paddock due to stock rotation - to give the paddock a 'rest'.

75084207 over 6 years ago

Multipolygon outer ways cannot share segments ..
see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=135.54507&lat=-31.29734&zoom=12

75103808 over 6 years ago

Multipolygon outer ways cannot share segments ..
see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=138.51576&lat=-31.34135&zoom=18

75093141 over 6 years ago

Not many places would run one cow. Glenlock station listed as a working farm ...
https://www.schoolactivities.com.au/school-activities-directory/glenloch-station
and a story to tellhttps://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/5992679/growing-up-on-the-glenloch-property-the-life-of-a-canberra-pioneer/

75093141 over 6 years ago

The arboretum is not in this area.

The relation has existed for some time before your edits. I use some QA tools to check for errors, usually daily .. there were no errors here before your past edit. Your past edit removed many ways from the relationship, some of these to update, but some of that removal caused the remaining relationship to become open.

You altered the tags from meadow to grassland so you must agree that there is that ground cover there?

Removing the relation makes the area around Glenloch appear blank on the map .. so there is nothing here? I think there is something here.. probably a meadow with mostly grasses. And you can see some evidence of it from imagery.

52747034 over 6 years ago

Hi
The Servicetonj Rec. Reserve pitch has sport=football .. that is too generic .. soccer, Ozie rules? Which 'football' is it?