Warin61's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 75103808 | about 6 years ago | Multipolygon outer ways cannot share segments ..
|
| 75093141 | about 6 years ago | Not many places would run one cow. Glenlock station listed as a working farm ...
|
| 75093141 | about 6 years ago | The arboretum is not in this area. The relation has existed for some time before your edits. I use some QA tools to check for errors, usually daily .. there were no errors here before your past edit. Your past edit removed many ways from the relationship, some of these to update, but some of that removal caused the remaining relationship to become open. You altered the tags from meadow to grassland so you must agree that there is that ground cover there? Removing the relation makes the area around Glenloch appear blank on the map .. so there is nothing here? I think there is something here.. probably a meadow with mostly grasses. And you can see some evidence of it from imagery. |
| 52747034 | about 6 years ago | Hi
|
| 65517972 | about 6 years ago | The name tag is not used for anything other than a name. Football is too generic, it could be soccer, ozie rules etc etc. In this case is appears to be rugby. |
| 75093141 | about 6 years ago | Reverted. relation/9385711 restored - Whitlam area not arboretum. Relation corrected as it should have been. Now has inners as well as a completed outer. |
| 75074150 | about 6 years ago | Done. Keep mapping, take care with any copyright issues too. |
| 74941403 | over 6 years ago | Ok, I just wondered where the name came from.. |
| 75054225 | over 6 years ago | The relation IS presently in error. It is not closed.
You can see that the orange line of the relation ways do not from a closed area. |
| 75074150 | over 6 years ago | Err no.
The second link shows the Mt Louisa- area as defense land and that appears to be already tagged. This is south of the area you have tried to tag as defense. relation/10094640, v1 is a duplication of relation Radar (10094639, v1)? The name 'Radar' appears to have no justification, possibly a description? |
| 75054225 | over 6 years ago | relation/9385711 is not closed. The removal of ways from it in this changeset is probably what caused it. |
| 74941403 | over 6 years ago | hi,
|
| 74990825 | over 6 years ago | Multipolygons; there separate ways cannot share segments. See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=119.10348&lat=-20.24295&zoom=18 Note these water ways will be seasonal only carrying water in the 'wet'. |
| 75008056 | over 6 years ago | Hi,
And a few more, 339639250 with 729079564 And wetland may not overlap a lake? Way: Lake Catani (729079567) with Way: 729079566?? |
| 73984430 | over 6 years ago | The OSM wiki on 'gardens' also goes on to say "A garden can have aesthetic, functional, and recreational uses". Cannot a garden have grassed areas? Or is it a question of the proportions of grass vs the rest? I think the main function of the area is as a botanical garden, not as a park. While many use it for relaxation, recreation (playing touch football for example) is done elsewhere (in the Domain locally). It is, to me, less of a park more of a garden. |
| 74749813 | over 6 years ago | There is a bit to learn. The OSM wiki can be useful for guidance.
|
| 74749813 | over 6 years ago | Hi,
The name key should only be used for a name not a description.
You have a node with the name 'foot bridge' changed from a ford=yes. This should be a section, some length not just a single node, tagged bridge=yes, layer=1. The bridge tag says it is a bridge, the layer tag says it is above the water. I take it you are a local - there is a lot to be mapped. |
| 74686814 | over 6 years ago | Goodo. OSM takes a while. Rather than use the name tag try the description tag?
|
| 74686814 | over 6 years ago | Hi
See
Both of these, to me, seem to be simple ways, no need for a relationship (no inners, not very long and no shared bits).
For the plant identification see species=* ---------------------------
PS is there a camp ground on the island? |
| 74604373 | over 6 years ago | Hi,
In this case a relationship is not required. Simply delete the relationship and add the tag natural=wood to the 3 ways. See
|