OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
27977115 about 7 years ago

Hi,
On Way: 320802992 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
I have not changed it, but I think it should be tagged natural=scrub.
See natural=scrub

37314580 about 7 years ago

Hi,
On closed Way: 67614774 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
I have not changed it, but I think it should be tagged natural=scrub.
See natural=scrub

47393471 about 7 years ago

Hi,
You have me puzzled (not hard to do :) )

On closed Way: 483503062 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
I have not changed it, but I think it should be tagged natural=scrub.
See natural=scrub

But you also have it tagged barrier=hedge. And a foot path going through the hedge.. umm

Is the outer a hedge.. probably with a hole in it for the path and then the inner scrub?
If so I would make a hole in the outer for the path, remove the tag for scrub on it. Then make a relation for the scrub using the hedge as most of the outer with a new way covering the hole for the path. I think that is the intention?

35457983 about 7 years ago

Hi,
On Way: 381444237 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
I have not changed it, but I think it should be tagged natural=scrub.
See natural=scrub

19329722 about 7 years ago

P.S I took a look at wayback machine for landuse=scrub .. https://web.archive.org/web/20110801000000*/https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:landuse%3Dscrub
No entry found there. If I could find an entry there then I might be able to justify an automatic change.

From April 2009 I got https://web.archive.org/web/20110312002352/http://wiki.openstreetmap.org:80/wiki/Land_use_and_areas_of_natural_land

And that has natural=scrub, no landuse=scrub.

19329722 about 7 years ago

I see it as 'housekeeping' - tiding up so that things are 'in order', conforming to present tagging practice.

I was told that I have to contact each contributor to advise them of this potential mistake in tagging and the potential correct tag. That imposes a fair degree of work on all, myself I'd rather just change them. But on the other hand contact is good too.

I do not believe OSM has 'everything quite right' now .. so I expect there may be changes in the future too, I hope there are - OSM should evolve.

37795077 about 7 years ago

Hi,
You have 'landuse=yes' on Way: 403431681

??? ummm what does that mean?

45705112 about 7 years ago

Hi,
You have 'landuse=yes' on Way: 470882539

??? ummm what does that mean?

22032726 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 278113429 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

16604643 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 226269754 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

42921156 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 447878335 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

44770029 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 462659048 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

40630997 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 324467140 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

63324128 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 631973710 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

40502809 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 429325406 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

26740050 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 310213093 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

57985523 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 578649115 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

42078070 about 7 years ago

Hello you :)

For Way: 441921493 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

37232401 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Way: 303633269 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.

12876588 about 7 years ago

Hi,

For Node: 1885038964 you have tagged landuse=scrub.
Scrub is not a 'landuse', in OSM the tag to use is 'natural=scrub'.